14 sections · ~42 min read
This content can't be printed from the browser. Use Export PDF with Pro for an offline copy.
IB Syllabus Requirements for Climate change—mitigation and adaptation
6.3.1
Global action to avoid catastrophic climate change
6.3.2
Decarbonization of the economy
6.3.3
Mitigation strategies
6.3.4
Adaptation strategies
6.3.1
GLOBAL ACTION TO AVOID CATASTROPHIC CLIMATE CHANGE
Greenhouse gases mix throughout the atmosphere. Emissions from one state therefore contribute to climate impacts far beyond its borders. Avoiding catastrophic climate change requires global action, not action limited to a few willing states. This starts to answer the topic’s guiding question: societies must tackle the causes through coordinated mitigation and manage unavoidable consequences through adaptation.
State sovereignty is the legal authority of a state to govern its own territory and make its own policies without control by another state. Governments can choose their own energy mix and emissions policy, but those decisions affect a shared atmosphere. International climate governance must balance state sovereignty against collective responsibility.
Countries negotiate international arrangements using the terms below. These terms overlap rather than forming a legal hierarchy: conventions and protocols can themselves be treaties.
The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change created the main negotiating framework. Later, the Kyoto Protocol imposed quantified commitments on participating developed states. The Paris Agreement instead requires parties to submit and strengthen nationally determined contributions. Although Paris has near-global participation, ambition and enforcement remain uneven because it relies on national pledges.
Example: Both the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and the Kyoto Protocol are treaties: each is a written agreement between states governed by international law. Their names describe their roles, not separate levels in a legal hierarchy.
Equity, development needs and energy security all shape international agreements, as does pressure from fossil-fuel interests. Cooperation can help spread technology and finance. Negotiations remain slow, though, because each state weighs global benefits against its own political and economic costs.
A cross-border carbon tax is a charge placed on imported goods according to the greenhouse gas emissions associated with their production. Such a tax can discourage firms from moving production to states with weaker climate policies. It can also pressure exporters to decarbonize. Affected states, however, may see it as protectionism, particularly when lower-income producers lack the finance needed for cleaner technology. Fairness depends on transparent calculation, exemptions or assistance, and recognition of different national capacities.
Worked example: An importer buys 2 tonnes of steel with embedded emissions of per tonne of steel. Calculate the additional import cost if the cross-border carbon charge is US$80 per tonne of . This simplified illustration ignores exemptions and recognition of carbon prices already paid.
Answer: The importer pays an additional US$320 on the 2 tonnes of steel.
Global cooperation takes more than signed documents. States need measurable commitments and transparent reporting, along with finance, technology transfer and credible incentives or sanctions. At the same time, they must retain enough flexibility to reflect national circumstances.
Exam tip: To evaluate international cooperation, support a judgement with evidence about an agreement’s coverage, implementation, monitoring and equity. Weigh strengths against limitations: participation or a signed target alone does not prove effectiveness. For example, Paris has near-global participation, but uneven ambition and enforcement limit what participation alone demonstrates.
6.3.2
DECARBONIZATION OF THE ECONOMY
Decarbonization of the economy means reducing or ending the use of energy sources that result in emissions and their replacement with renewable energy sources. In practice, this involves phasing down fossil fuels and expanding low-carbon electricity. It also requires better energy efficiency and the electrification of activities such as transport and heating. However, electrification only cuts emissions substantially if the electricity comes from low-carbon sources. A battery vehicle powered by coal-heavy electricity is not fully decarbonized.
Important routes include:
Carbon neutrality is a condition in which the net release of is zero because remaining emissions are balanced by an equivalent removal of from the atmosphere. The target may cover a company, activity, city or state. Net zero greenhouse gas emissions is a condition in which all remaining greenhouse gas emissions are balanced by equivalent removals. This is broader than carbon neutrality because it covers gases other than .
Worked example: A company reduces annual emissions from 100,000 to 10,000 tonnes of and verifies atmospheric removals of 10,000 tonnes of per year. Calculate its emissions balance.
The balance separates reductions at source from atmospheric removals.
Answer: Net emissions are , so the company is carbon neutral within this boundary. If it also releases residual methane without further balancing removals, it has not achieved net-zero greenhouse gas emissions.
Targets differ widely. Some states have selected dates in the 2040s, many aim for around mid-century, while others have chosen dates after 2060. These dates reflect historical emissions and development priorities, as well as access to finance, available technology and political willingness.
Example: The United Kingdom and Sweden illustrate national targets in place as of 2024. Compare their coverage and implementation, not just their dates.
| State | Net-zero target year | Scope | Interim implementation measure |
|---|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom | 2050 | All greenhouse gases | Legally binding five-year carbon budgets |
| Sweden | 2045 | All greenhouse gases | Carbon tax on fossil fuels |
A distant target is only convincing if interim carbon budgets, sector plans and monitoring support it. Without them, the target can postpone difficult action. Comparing dates without comparing scope can mislead: a -only target does not cover all greenhouse gases.
Offsets can balance residual emissions, but they can’t replace deep reductions. Carbon stored in forests may later be released through fire or land-use change. Poorly verified projects may also claim removals that would have happened anyway. Decarbonization should reduce emissions at source first, reserving removals for the hardest activities to eliminate. Credits for avoided emissions do not represent atmospheric removals and cannot be subtracted as removals in this balance.
6.3.3
MITIGATION STRATEGIES
Climate change mitigation is deliberate action that limits climate change by reducing warming, reducing greenhouse gas emissions or increasing the removal of from the atmosphere. These categories can overlap. Even so, separating them makes it easier to see what each proposal changes.
These approaches reduce the warming produced by a given greenhouse gas concentration.
Households can slow warming indirectly by using less energy. Insulation, lower thermostat settings and passive cooling cut demand for fuel and electricity, though the energy source determines the final emissions saving.
Carbon capture and storage is a method of reducing emissions by capturing the gas from power generation or industry, transporting it and permanently storing it underground. Capturing at concentrated sources can tackle some industrial emissions. Conventional point-source CCS captures fossil-fuel or industrial before it reaches the atmosphere, so it reduces emissions rather than removing atmospheric .
A carbon sink is a reservoir that absorbs more carbon than it releases over a specified period. Restoring forests and protecting peatlands can expand natural sinks while supporting biodiversity and water regulation.
Rewilding is a form of environmental restoration aimed at restoring natural processes and increasing biodiversity. Woodland, wetland and grassland that have been restored may accumulate carbon, but the amount and permanence differ among ecosystems.
Afforestation is establishing a forest in an area where there was no forest before. As trees grow, they take up . Poorly designed plantations, however, can compete with food production, reduce water availability or offer little biodiversity value.
The source of the captured carbon determines how a capture strategy is classified.
| Strategy | Source and process | Mitigation category |
|---|---|---|
| Conventional point-source CCS | Captures fossil-fuel or industrial before release and stores it underground. | Emissions reduction: prevents an addition to the atmosphere. |
| Direct air capture with permanent storage | Removes dispersed atmospheric and stores it underground. | Atmospheric removal, provided the amount stored exceeds the lifecycle emissions of capture and storage. |
| Bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) | Biomass takes up atmospheric as it grows; energy production releases this carbon, which is captured and permanently stored. | Can achieve net atmospheric removal if the carbon stored exceeds all lifecycle emissions, including those from biomass production, land-use change, processing, transport and capture. |
Conventional CCS and direct air capture both need energy, infrastructure, secure geological storage and long-term monitoring. For BECCS, biomass sourcing and changes in ecosystem carbon stocks also affect whether net removal is achieved.
Common mistake: Classifying all carbon capture as atmospheric removal. Conventional fossil-fuel or industrial point-source CCS reduces emissions before release; direct air capture removes carbon already in the atmosphere. BECCS can count as net removal because biomass first takes up atmospheric carbon, but only when permanent storage exceeds the system's lifecycle emissions.
No single strategy will be enough. Effective mitigation combines lower demand and clean energy with ecosystem protection and carefully governed removals. Future carbon removal should not become an excuse to continue emissions.
6.3.4
ADAPTATION STRATEGIES
Climate change adaptation is adjustment to actual or expected climate change that reduces adverse effects or maximizes positive consequences. It manages the impacts of climate change rather than removing their climatic cause. Past emissions and delayed responses in the climate system mean that some warming and sea-level rise are already unavoidable. Both mitigation and adaptation are therefore necessary.
Example: Elevating a building is adaptation because it reduces flood damage. Replacing fossil-fuel electricity with solar generation is mitigation because it reduces greenhouse gas emissions.
Exam tip: Explain the mechanism, not just the category: state how the action reduces damage from a climate hazard or reduces emissions that cause climate change.
A structural adaptation is a physical structure or engineered change that reduces exposure or vulnerability to a climate hazard. Examples include:
A non-structural adaptation is a change in rules, behaviour, knowledge or management that reduces climate risk without relying mainly on a new protective structure. Examples include:
| Type of adaptation | Strengths | Limitations |
|---|---|---|
| Structural measures | Often provide visible and immediate protection. | Can be expensive and may shift risk elsewhere. For example, a flood wall can speed up water flow towards an unprotected community. |
| Non-structural measures | Tend to be cheaper and more flexible. | Rely on compliance, effective institutions and public trust. |
There are limits to adaptation. As hazards intensify, protection may become technically or financially unfeasible. Ecosystems can also cross thresholds beyond which management cannot restore their previous state. Benefits may be uneven: wealthy districts might receive protection while poorer or informal communities remain exposed.
When creating a survey about a proposed local mitigation solution, start with one clear proposal, such as installing solar panels on school buildings. Define the target population, then choose an appropriate sampling method. Comparisons between groups should use similar sample sizes and identical wording for each group.
Open with a short, neutral explanation of the proposal. Avoid leading language in the questions. Include closed questions for quantitative comparison, along with a small number of open questions, and collect only demographic information that is relevant. One useful rating item could ask respondents to score their support on a consistent five-point scale.
Example: “How strongly do you support installing solar panels on school buildings?” Ask respondents to select one response: 1 — Strongly oppose; 2 — Somewhat oppose; 3 — Neither support nor oppose; 4 — Somewhat support; 5 — Strongly support.
Pilot the questionnaire with a few people and revise any ambiguous items. Obtain informed consent and preserve anonymity.
Present the results as percentages or grouped bar charts, comparing attitudes by age group or stakeholder group.
Worked example: In a hypothetical survey of 30 respondents, 18 select either “Somewhat support” or “Strongly support”. Calculate the percentage of respondents who support installing solar panels on school buildings.
Answer: Support is of the sample. This describes the respondents surveyed; it does not prove that of the target population supports the proposal.
The conclusion should acknowledge sampling bias and non-response, as well as the gap between stated attitudes and actual behaviour.
6.3.5
ADAPTATION PLANS
An adaptation plan is a coordinated programme that identifies climate risks, selects responses, assigns responsibilities and monitors results. Planning takes place at several scales:
| Scale | Responses and responsibilities |
|---|---|
| Household | Individuals might prepare for heat or flooding. |
| Community | Communities can set up cooling centres or plan evacuation routes. |
| City and state | Cities and states coordinate land use, infrastructure, health, agriculture and water management. |
National Adaptation Programmes of Action are national planning documents through which eligible developing countries identify and prioritize urgent adaptation needs. Wider resilience and adaptation plans may look further ahead. They can be reviewed repeatedly as climate projections and social conditions change.
A sound planning cycle involves the following linked activities:
The cycle links monitoring back to risk assessment, with community participation informing every stage.
Through the UN Development Programme, developing countries can obtain assistance in formulating local priority activities that address imminent climate consequences. This support may include:
Local participation matters. A plan may be technically impressive but still fail if it overlooks livelihoods, customary land use or unequal access to resources. Affected communities should help select priorities rather than simply having decisions delivered to them. Community participation should inform data collection, assessment, comparison of options, prioritization, implementation and monitoring.
Example: In coastal Bangladesh, the UNDP-supported project Community-based Adaptation to Climate Change through Coastal Afforestation in Bangladesh addressed cyclone and storm-surge risks. Community consultation informed the priority of combining coastal protection with more secure, diversified livelihoods. Bangladesh’s Forest Department implemented the project, with UNDP support and funding from the Global Environment Facility’s Least Developed Countries Fund. Planned activities included coastal afforestation and livelihood diversification; implementation included community-based planting and livelihood activities. A measurable monitoring indicator is the area of coastal land planted, measured in hectares. This records an implementation output: it does not, by itself, demonstrate that households suffered fewer cyclone losses or became less vulnerable. Source: UNDP Adaptation, project profile for Community-based Adaptation to Climate Change through Coastal Afforestation in Bangladesh.
Plans must also avoid maladaptation, which is an intervention intended to reduce climate risk but which instead increases vulnerability, emissions or inequality. For example, air conditioning powered by fossil fuels may protect people from heat in the short term while increasing emissions. Hard coastal defences may encourage further development in an area that cannot be protected indefinitely.
6.3.6
GOVERNMENTAL AND NON-GOVERNMENTAL RESPONSES
Governments can tax, regulate, spend public money and coordinate infrastructure at a national level. Other stakeholders—firms, investors, NGOs, communities and individuals—can change how goods are produced and financed, what people consume and what the public expects. Effective action usually depends on several groups working together, rather than one acting alone.
Carbon pricing makes emitters pay at least part of the social cost of greenhouse gas pollution. In an emissions trading system, a government sets an emissions limit, distributes or auctions permits and allows regulated emitters to trade those permits. If the cap declines, emissions can be made to fall. Trading then channels reductions towards the firms that can achieve them most cheaply. However, weak caps or too many free permits limit the system’s impact.
Worked example: Two firms, A and B, initially emit each. The regulator gives each firm 90 permits, with each permit allowing emissions of . The fixed cap is therefore . Abatement costs are constant at US$20 per tonne for A and US$60 per tonne for B. At a permit price of US$40 per tonne, compare trading with each firm cutting emissions by .
Without trading, each firm cuts emissions by . Costs, measured in US dollars, are:
With trading, A finds it cheaper to abate than to retain permits: its abatement cost is US$20 per tonne, below the US$40 permit price. A abates , leaving emissions of . It needs only 80 of its 90 permits, so sells 10 permits to B. B buys these permits because US$40 per tonne is cheaper than its US$60 abatement cost. B makes no cuts and emits .
B pays A US$400 for the 10 permits. A's abatement expenditure is also US$400, so its net cost is US$0. B's net cost is US$400. The payment is a transfer between firms, not an additional abatement cost. Total abatement cost, in US dollars, is:
Check emissions against the cap:
The saving in total abatement costs, in US dollars, is:
Answer: Trading achieves the same total emissions of at an abatement cost of US$400 rather than US$800, saving US$400. Reductions occur at the lower-cost firm without changing the cap.
The schematic tracks permits and payment while the emissions cap stays fixed.
A subsidy is an amount of money provided by government to help an industry or business keep the price of its goods or services low. Support for building insulation or clean electricity can speed up adoption. If subsidies are poorly targeted, though, they may reward activities that would have happened anyway.
A tariff is a customs duty imposed on imported goods. Climate-related tariffs may discourage carbon-intensive imports, but they can also increase prices and cause trade disputes.
Example: British Columbia’s carbon tax provides an economic example. It raised the price of fossil fuels, then recycled the revenue through tax reductions and payments. Households and firms gained an incentive to use less fuel, although the impact depends on the tax rate, the alternatives available and protection for low-income households.
The United Kingdom’s Climate Change Act set legally binding long-term emissions targets and created a system of carbon budgets. This makes climate policy more durable than a single government announcement and supports independent scrutiny. Even so, legislation needs detailed policies and enforcement. A target by itself won’t close the gap between promises and delivery.
Example: Urgenda, a Dutch NGO, used climate litigation to challenge the adequacy of the Netherlands government’s emissions reductions. In 2019, the Dutch Supreme Court upheld an order requiring the state to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by at least 25% below 1990 levels by the end of 2020, drawing on the state’s human-rights obligations to protect life and private and family life. The government responded with an additional emissions-reduction package, including restrictions on coal-fired electricity generation. Litigation therefore turned NGO pressure into a legally enforceable obligation, but a court order still depends on government implementation and enforcement. Sources: Dutch Supreme Court judgment ECLI:NL:HR:2019:2007; Netherlands government’s April 2020 response to the Urgenda judgment.
Businesses may:
Example: Microsoft charges its business divisions an internal carbon fee. The revenue supports emissions reduction and removal. Measures like these can shape investment decisions and influence suppliers, but voluntary goals need clear boundaries and independent verification to prevent greenwashing.
People can cut waste, meat consumption and household energy demand. They may also choose lower-carbon transport and support political change. Such choices lower personal emissions while shifting social norms and markets. Infrastructure and income still constrain their effect: asking someone to give up a car isn’t realistic if safe, affordable public transport doesn’t exist.
When investigating regional or national policy, first separate mitigation from adaptation.
6.3.7
THE UN AND GLOBAL CLIMATE STRATEGIES
The United Nations has been the main arena for countries to cooperate on climate change. The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change is an international convention whose objective is to stabilize greenhouse gas concentrations at a level that prevents dangerous human interference with the climate system.
The Conference of the Parties is the regular meeting at which parties to a convention review implementation and negotiate further decisions. Through COP meetings, parties have produced or advanced agreements, finance arrangements and reporting rules, as well as national commitments.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change is a UN body that assesses published scientific knowledge about climate change, its impacts and possible responses. It neither carries out original research nor sets government policy. Instead, its assessments give UNFCCC negotiations a shared evidence base.
| Institution or meeting | Distinct role |
|---|---|
| UNFCCC | Supplies the treaty framework for international climate cooperation. |
| COP | Provides the meetings where parties negotiate decisions. |
| IPCC | Assesses scientific evidence rather than negotiating policy. |
At COP29 in Baku in 2024, parties agreed on a new climate-finance goal. Developed countries would take the lead in mobilizing at least US$300 billion per year for developing countries by 2035. Alongside this, parties set a wider ambition to scale flows from public and private sources to US$1.3 trillion per year. They also completed important rules for carbon-market cooperation under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement.
Supporters argued that the agreement established a larger, more explicit finance framework. Critics said the core amount was still far below estimated needs. They also argued that it depended too heavily on mobilized finance rather than guaranteed public finance and failed to resolve the debt burden that loans may create. COP outcomes should therefore be judged by implementation, not just headline pledges.
The Montreal Protocol first dealt with ozone-depleting substances. However, some of the substitutes were powerful greenhouse gases, even though they did not destroy ozone. The Kigali Amendment added a global phase-down of hydrofluorocarbons, or HFCs. Related hydrochlorofluorocarbons, or HCFCs, were already controlled under the Montreal Protocol because they deplete ozone and also contribute to warming.
The IB syllabus describes the link as the Kigali Amendment controlling HCFCs allowed by the Montreal Protocol that subsequently proved to be greenhouse-gas emissions. This wording needs a terminology distinction: Kigali specifically phases down HFCs, whereas HCFCs are controlled through the Montreal Protocol's ozone-protection provisions. The underlying link is that replacing ozone-depleting substances can introduce substitutes that contribute to climate change, requiring further international controls.
Kigali shows how an existing treaty can be amended when scientific evidence identifies an additional environmental problem. Its effectiveness depends on:
6.3.8
IPCC EMISSIONS SCENARIOS
An emissions scenario is a modelled possible future pathway based on stated assumptions about society, technology, policy and greenhouse gas emissions. It explores what could happen under a particular set of conditions rather than claiming that one future is certain.
The IPCC uses five broad pathways, ranging from very low to very high future emissions. Such a range is needed because we cannot know future population, energy systems, economic development, international cooperation or climate policy in advance.
Shared socioeconomic pathways are scenarios describing alternative patterns of social and economic development that can be combined with different levels of climate forcing.
Example: In SSP2–4.5, SSP2 identifies the socioeconomic storyline, while 4.5 denotes an approximate radiative forcing level of in 2100 relative to pre-industrial conditions. The suffix is not a temperature increase.
The five commonly used pathways are:
First, check the variable, units, baseline period and time axis. Don’t confuse a line’s central estimate with its uncertainty range. Near-term temperature projections overlap because past emissions and climate-system inertia have a strong influence on the next few decades. Later in the century, the lines separate more clearly as the differences in cumulative emissions grow.
In the IPCC Sixth Assessment, the approximate best estimates of warming for 2081–2100 relative to 1850–1900 are:
| Scenario | Best estimate of warming |
|---|---|
| SSP1–1.9 | |
| SSP1–2.6 | |
| SSP2–4.5 | |
| SSP3–7.0 | |
| SSP5–8.5 |
Worked example: Compare the late-century best estimates of warming under the very high and very low emissions scenarios. State the period and baseline, and explain why the comparison is not a certain prediction.
Answer: For 2081–2100 relative to 1850–1900, the best estimate of warming under SSP5–8.5 is greater than under SSP1–1.9. These outcomes are conditional on each scenario’s assumptions, rather than certain predictions.
The effects won’t be spatially uniform. Land generally warms more than oceans, while high northern latitudes warm especially strongly. Higher-emission pathways increase the likelihood and intensity of heat extremes, heavy precipitation and drought in vulnerable regions. They also increase ice loss, sea-level rise, coastal flooding and erosion. As a result, a global mean conceals substantial regional differences.
Scenarios allow scientists to compare risks and test policy choices. However, they include uncertainty linked to future human decisions, climate sensitivity and model representation. That uncertainty gives us a reason to compare pathways and manage risk—not to assume that no action is needed.
6.3.9
TECHNOLOGY FOR CLIMATE MITIGATION
A socially embedded technology is a technological system whose effectiveness depends on its integration with people, institutions and everyday behaviour. Simply having a sensor or app won’t reduce emissions. It needs to supply useful information, remain accessible and influence people’s decisions.
Smart-city applications have many uses. They can direct drivers to available charging stations, identify nearby recycling facilities, coordinate public transport and detect water leakage. They may also adjust electricity demand. Sensors and digital networks can improve the efficiency of urban systems, but their energy use and electronic waste must be considered, along with privacy implications and unequal accessibility.
Universities and research centres help industry develop low-carbon materials, improved batteries, carbon-capture methods and more efficient industrial processes. Collaboration can take an idea from research through to commercial deployment. However, adoption may be slowed by cost, intellectual-property restrictions and infrastructure.
Amsterdam has implemented connected charging infrastructure for electric vehicles. Charging-point data can identify demand and guide users to available stations. It also helps operators decide where extra capacity is needed. Smart charging can move vehicle charging away from periods of peak electricity demand and towards times when more renewable electricity is available.
The mitigation benefit comes from enabling electric mobility and reducing unnecessary travel while drivers search for chargers. It also supports better use of low-carbon electricity. These benefits aren’t automatic: they depend on the carbon intensity of the grid, public access, battery and vehicle production, and whether electric vehicles replace fossil-fuel travel rather than adding to total traffic.
This example shows why implementation matters. The technology forms part of a wider system that includes electricity generation, transport planning, pricing, data governance and citizen behaviour.
6.3.10
CHALLENGES TO CLIMATE MANAGEMENT
Some people don’t see climate change as serious, immediate or mainly caused by humans. This may stem from:
When people deny the problem or view it as distant, voters and consumers are less willing to bear costs now for benefits that come later.
Effective climate strategies depend on finance, technical expertise, data, stable institutions and long-term planning. Governments dealing with poverty, conflict, debt or urgent health and education needs may have little capacity left to pay for sea defences, clean-energy grids or climate monitoring.
International finance can help. However, loans may add to existing debt, while complex application procedures can shut out states with the least administrative capacity.
Climate action can stall if individuals, NGOs, political leaders or transnational companies don’t coordinate or take responsibility. A transnational company is a company with operations in more than one country. These companies can spread low-carbon technology across markets. On the other hand, firms linked to fossil fuels may lobby against regulation or keep investing in carbon-intensive assets.
NGOs may provide expertise and put pressure on governments, but they can lack formal power or secure funding. Political leaders, meanwhile, may avoid policies that impose short-term costs despite large long-term benefits. Leadership therefore needs support from institutions, accountability and participation instead of depending on one prominent person.
Economies that export fossil fuels gain revenue, employment and geopolitical influence from continued extraction. A rapid transition may therefore threaten livelihoods and public finances. Importing states may prefer faster change because it can improve energy security. High-income countries generally have better access to finance and technology; low-income countries may be more vulnerable despite having contributed less to the problem.
Resistance is likely when a transition is seen as unfair. A just transition is a process of environmental change that distributes costs and benefits fairly while supporting affected workers and communities. Retraining, regional investment, social protection and climate finance can limit opposition without giving up emissions goals.
Example: France’s 2018 fuel-tax protests show how distributional concerns can undermine public acceptance. The proposed fuel-tax increase raised concerns about living costs, particularly for households dependent on cars with few transport alternatives. Following the “yellow vest” protests, the government cancelled the planned increase. Cancellation addressed the immediate opposition but weakened the price incentive to reduce fossil-fuel use. A more durable response would pair carbon pricing with targeted household support and affordable transport alternatives, rather than assume opposition makes climate action impossible. Source: International Energy Agency, France 2021: Energy Policy Review.
Example: South Africa’s energy transition faces linked constraints: coal supports employment and local economies, investment requires finance, and electricity shortages make supply security urgent. Its Just Energy Transition Investment Plan prioritises electricity-system investment alongside skills and support for affected communities. Grid investment and replacement generating capacity can address energy-security concerns, while worker support can reduce opposition to coal closures. However, implementation still depends on securing suitable finance and delivering these measures before communities lose livelihoods. Sources: South Africa’s Presidential Climate Commission, A Framework for a Just Transition in South Africa; Government of South Africa, Just Energy Transition Investment Plan.
Different groups may weigh climate risks and policy costs differently:
| Group or setting | Possible perspective |
|---|---|
| Younger people | May feel greater urgency because they’ll live with long-term impacts for longer. |
| Some older people | May place more weight on immediate costs. |
| Coastal and low-lying communities | Direct exposure to flooding, erosion and saline intrusion may encourage support for rapid adaptation. |
| Inland or upland groups | May see less immediate danger. |
These patterns are broad tendencies rather than fixed rules. Within every group, wealth, occupation, education, political identity and personal experience create substantial variation. Climate management isn’t merely a technical challenge: it also depends on trust, power, fairness and whose knowledge shapes decisions.
Exam tip: For an “Evaluate challenges” question, identify a barrier, explain how it affects implementation, support the explanation with a named case, consider a policy response, then judge the barrier’s importance in that context. Weigh barriers against one another rather than simply listing them: ask which is most restrictive, whether it can be reduced, and whether reducing it also eases another barrier.
Worked example: Evaluate how finance and public acceptance can interact to constrain climate management.
Answer: In South Africa, finance is a major enabling constraint because electricity investment and support for affected workers both require funding. However, finance and public acceptance reinforce one another: funding can make the transition fairer and more reliable, while public support helps sustain the policies needed to deliver investment.
6.3.11
GEOENGINEERING
Geoengineering is a deliberate and large-scale intervention in the Earth’s climate system. Solar radiation modification changes Earth’s energy balance without lowering atmospheric , whereas carbon dioxide removal lowers atmospheric but does not itself stop new emissions. Neither approach replaces the need to address the underlying social cause of climate change—continued greenhouse gas emissions.
Geoengineering proposals generally fit into two groups: solar radiation modification and greenhouse gas removal.
Solar radiation modification seeks to reflect a greater proportion of incoming solar energy back into space.
None of these measures would remove , prevent ocean acidification or address every regional climate effect. If a successful programme ended abruptly while greenhouse gas concentrations were still high, rapid warming could follow.
Geoengineering could offer extra options if emissions cuts happen too slowly or severe impacts become imminent.
The costs could be extremely high, while the impacts remain uncertain. Few proposals have undergone convincing large-scale trials because testing at a planetary scale is itself risky. Political hesitation is understandable when benefits and harms may be shared unevenly.
There is also a moral hazard, which is a situation in which protection from a risk encourages behaviour that makes the underlying risk greater. Belief in a future technological fix could reduce efforts to cut emissions now.
Geopolitical conflict could develop over control of a climate intervention or the preferred global temperature. Other disputes could concern liability for harmful side effects and whether one state can act without international consent. Geoengineering therefore needs international governance and transparent research, alongside public participation. Clear rules would also be required for monitoring and termination. Its potential is best viewed as a possible supplement to rapid mitigation—not a replacement for it.
Worked example: Evaluate stratospheric aerosol injection as a response to climate change.
Answer: Stratospheric aerosol injection offers potentially rapid cooling, but precipitation uncertainty, termination risk and disputes over control limit its acceptability. It could be considered only as a supplement to rapid emissions cuts if evidence and international governance were sufficient to manage these risks, not as a replacement for mitigation.
Exam tip: Evaluate the named technique rather than geoengineering as a whole: explain its mechanism, weigh a specific benefit against its risks, and reach a conditional judgement. Do not transfer identical benefits and risks to all methods; rapid cooling and termination risk are not shared in the same way by carbon dioxide removal.
6.3.12
STAKEHOLDERS AND CHANGING PERSPECTIVES
A stakeholder is a person, group or organization that affects, is affected by, or has an interest in a decision or issue. Everyone has a stake in climate change. However, stakeholders vary widely in their exposure, authority, expertise, resources and access to media.
A charismatic individual can turn complex evidence into a memorable moral or political message. Their visibility may motivate people who once viewed climate change as a remote issue. Yet personal authority can oversimplify evidence, and its influence depends heavily on whether the audience trusts the speaker.
Example: Greta Thunberg’s demand for urgent climate action spread through school strikes, youth networks and media coverage to students and wider audiences. Fridays for Future’s international strikes demonstrate participation and message diffusion, but do not alone establish lasting attitude change among participants or observers.
Local community groups link climate change to direct experiences such as flooding, heat or energy costs. They offer local knowledge, organize practical action and build trust. Their focus can be narrow, though, and one vocal group may not represent the whole community.
NGOs conduct research, campaign, litigate and monitor governments and firms. They also provide assistance. This can bring neglected evidence onto the public agenda, but funding sources and campaign methods shape how people perceive their claims.
Example: WWF’s Earth Hour asks people to switch off non-essential lights as a signal of environmental concern. Websites, media coverage and community events carry the message to households and organizations. The campaign documents landmark participation, including the Sydney Opera House (source: Earth Hour). This demonstrates a visible response, not necessarily lasting changes in attitudes or energy use.
Media organizations decide which stories receive attention and how to frame them. Accurate reporting can explain risk and expose misleading claims. By contrast, repeated sensationalism or false balance may create fear, fatigue or the impression that established science is evenly disputed.
Educational institutions develop the knowledge people need to interpret evidence, distinguish weather from climate and evaluate proposed responses. They may also host research and public discussion. Education works best when it develops critical understanding rather than telling students what to think.
Power shapes stakeholder influence. Governments can legislate and fund infrastructure. Corporations may alter investment and supply chains, or lobby against controls. Social media can widen participation, but repetition and algorithmic filtering can also amplify misinformation. An individual’s perspective develops through interactions among evidence, values, identity, experience and trusted sources.
Exam tip: Compare two stakeholders using reach, trust, evidence quality and decision-making power. For example, a campaigner may reach more people than a local council, while the council can change planning policy. Wide sharing demonstrates visibility, not credibility or changed behaviour: assess evidence quality separately and look for observed actions or policy decisions before claiming influence.
6.3.13
CONTRASTING PERSPECTIVES ON CLIMATE ACTION
A perspective is a particular way of understanding an issue shaped by knowledge, experience, values and circumstances. People can agree that climate change is occurring but still disagree about the need for action, whether a proposed response is practical, or how quickly it should happen.
Younger people may prefer rapid action because much of the future damage will occur within their lifetimes. Delaying mitigation also transfers costs to them. Some older people may give greater priority to current energy prices, pensions or employment. However, many strongly support action because they are concerned about their descendants, and younger people don’t form a single political group either. Age influences perspective, but it doesn’t explain it completely.
High-income societies usually have more financial and technological capacity to mitigate and adapt. Insurance, infrastructure and emergency services may leave their populations feeling partly protected. Yet these societies also tend to consume more and carry substantial historical responsibility.
Developing societies may focus on poverty reduction, energy access or employment. Restrictions on development can seem unfair when richer countries industrialized using fossil fuels. At the same time, climate action may feel highly urgent because of exposure to drought, heat, flooding or climate-sensitive livelihoods. Finance and technology transfer can make low-carbon development more practical.
For coastal and low-lying communities, sea-level rise, storm surges, erosion and saline intrusion can make adaptation and rapid mitigation seem immediately necessary. Inland and upland communities may feel less threatened by sea-level rise, although they can still face wildfire, water scarcity, heat and river flooding. Direct experience often increases concern. Wealth and protective infrastructure, however, can reduce perceived vulnerability.
In economies that depend on coal, oil or gas, governments, workers and firms may focus on export revenue, employment or energy security. They may favour slower change, carbon capture or compensation for affected regions. Economies without profitable fossil reserves may view renewable energy as a way to reduce imports, price exposure and pollution, though new infrastructure still carries a cost.
Example: In South Africa, the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM) and the South African Photovoltaic Industry Association (SAPVIA) emphasize different transition priorities. NUM represents coal workers among others: its just-transition position stresses protecting employment and livelihoods. For NUM, action must address social needs; practical implementation requires replacement jobs and reliable electricity, making unsupported closures unacceptable. SAPVIA represents solar businesses: it promotes solar investment as necessary for cleaner, more secure electricity. It favours urgent deployment, while grid access and investment conditions affect practicality. Solar businesses also anticipate employment opportunities. These are stakeholder positions, not the views of all South Africans. Sources: NUM’s public statements on the just transition and SAPVIA’s industry and policy publications.
These are possible tendencies, not universal positions.
| Comparison pair | Necessity | Practicality | Urgency | Within-group variation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Younger / older people | Future damage / current welfare | Costs across generations | Lifetime exposure / immediate pressures | Values differ within ages |
| Developed / developing societies | Historical responsibility / development needs | Greater capacity / finance constraints | Protection may buffer concern / exposure may intensify it | Wealth and vulnerability vary |
| Coastal / inland communities | Coastal hazards / other climate hazards | Resources shape protection | Direct exposure can heighten urgency | Infrastructure changes vulnerability |
| Fossil-fuel / non-fossil-fuel economies | Livelihood security / reduced import dependence | Replacement jobs / infrastructure investment | Managed transition / faster diversification | Workers, firms and governments differ |
These differences help explain why a universal policy can produce very different reactions. Cooperation becomes more likely when policy recognizes legitimate development needs, protects vulnerable groups and offers credible alternatives for workers and communities. Perspectives may shift as impacts become more visible, technologies become cheaper or trusted stakeholders present new evidence.
Exam tip: Explain contrasts through circumstances, not labels. A model comparative paragraph is: “Both NUM and SAPVIA emphasize electricity security, whereas NUM places greater weight on protecting existing workers because coal employment supports livelihoods. SAPVIA favours faster solar investment because its members develop renewable-energy businesses.” Explaining either perspective does not mean endorsing it.
6.3.14
CLIMATE CHANGE AND THE TRAGEDY OF THE COMMONS
The tragedy of the commons is a situation in which individuals or states acting in their own short-term interest overuse or degrade a shared resource because the costs are distributed among all users. In the context of climate change, this suggests that catastrophic change is likely unless countries cooperate on an unprecedented scale.
The atmosphere is a global common. By burning fossil fuels, a state receives concentrated benefits such as energy, tax revenue, industrial output and employment. The climatic costs, however, fall across all states, people and ecosystems. Much of the benefit stays with the emitting state, while it bears only part of the damage.
The incentive works in reverse too. If a state pays for carbon capture, forest restoration or a rapid energy transition, it carries much of the immediate cost, but the climatic benefit is shared worldwide. Each state may wait for others to pay, producing free-riding, which is obtaining the benefit of collective action without contributing a fair share of its cost.
Worked example: In a hypothetical two-state world, each mitigation programme costs the state funding it US$10 million and produces US$8 million in benefits for each state. Calculate each state's net benefit when only one state acts and when both act. Assume the benefits of the two programmes add together.
Calculate the contributor's net benefit when it acts alone. All values in the calculations are in millions of US dollars:
Calculate the other state's net benefit when it does not contribute:
Calculate each state's net benefit when both act. Each receives benefits from both programmes but pays for only its own:
| Hypothetical outcome | State A net benefit / million US dollars | State B net benefit / million US dollars |
|---|---|---|
| Only State A acts | ||
| Only State B acts | ||
| Both states act |
Answer: Acting alone gives the contributor a US$2 million net loss and the other state a US$8 million gain; both acting gives each a US$6 million net gain. Although cooperation benefits both compared with neither acting, each state individually gains more by not paying, whatever the other does: individual incentives conflict with the collective interest.
This problem crosses national borders and generations, and it affects almost every economic sector. No single global government can impose and enforce one policy everywhere. States also have different levels of historical responsibility, present emissions, vulnerability and financial capacity. Reaching agreement on a fair contribution is therefore difficult.
Shared targets and transparent emissions reporting can change these incentives. So can climate finance, technology transfer, carbon pricing and sanctions against free-riding. Repeated negotiations may build trust, while common measurement rules make inaction harder to hide.
Any cooperation must also be equitable. Identical reductions may be politically unacceptable and ethically weak when states have very different historical emissions and development needs. Under differentiated responsibilities, wealthier, higher-emitting states can cut faster and provide support, while every state contributes according to its capacity.
The tragedy isn’t inevitable. Users can manage commons when they recognize their mutual dependence, agree on rules, monitor compliance and see the distribution of costs as legitimate. Climate change makes this exceptionally difficult: the common is planetary, and the consequences unfold over long time scales. That’s why isolated national measures cannot be enough.
Exam tip: Explain, then evaluate. First trace the mechanism: concentrated benefits encourage emissions, dispersed costs weaken the incentive to limit them, and shared mitigation benefits encourage free-riding. Then assess how monitoring could expose inaction, differentiated responsibilities could make contributions more acceptable, and incentives could change the costs and benefits of cooperation. Judge these measures against the difficulties of enforcement and fairness; do not assume they guarantee success. Defining the commons alone does not explain why it is overused.