Clastify logo
Subjects
Features
Review
HOT Save 10%
Tutoring
Log in

6.2: Climate change—causes and impacts

Master IB ESS 6.2: Climate change—causes and impacts with notes created by examiners and strictly aligned with the syllabus.

Verified by Veronica
Verified by Veronica

15 sections · ~28 min read

This content can't be printed from the browser. Use Export PDF with Pro for an offline copy.

IB Syllabus Requirements for Climate change—causes and impacts

6.2.1

Climate and atmospheric processes

6.2.2

Anthropogenic carbon dioxide emissions

6.2.3

Evidence from climate proxies

6.2.4

The enhanced greenhouse effect

6.2.1

CLIMATE AND ATMOSPHERIC PROCESSES

Climate describes the usual conditions produced by physical processes in the atmosphere. These conditions come from long-term observations, not from a single unusual season or storm.

Climate and weather aren't the same. Weather is the state of the atmosphere at a particular place over a short period, while climate covers the characteristic pattern and variability expected over much longer periods.

Temperature and precipitation

An area's climate is mainly described through seasonal variations in temperature and precipitation. Timing matters just as much as annual averages. Two places may receive the same yearly rainfall but have very different climates: one might get rain throughout the year, while the other has a single short wet season.

These seasonal patterns are influenced by latitude, altitude, distance from the sea, prevailing winds, ocean currents and topography. A mountain, for example, may force moist air upwards. This produces precipitation on the windward side and drier conditions in the rain shadow.

A climate graph is a combined graph that shows a location's mean monthly temperature and precipitation. First, use the temperature line to identify the annual range and seasonal peaks. Then check the precipitation bars for the total amount and any wet or dry seasons. Finally, look at how the patterns interact—for example, whether the warmest months are also the driest.

6.2.2

ANTHROPOGENIC CARBON DIOXIDE EMISSIONS

The historical increase

Anthropogenic emissions are releases produced by human activities. Human emissions of CO2CO_2 have driven a significant rise in its atmospheric concentration. This increase began during the Industrial Revolution in late eighteenth-century Europe, as coal-powered machinery started to replace human, animal and renewable energy on a large scale.

Industrialization then spread, fossil-fuel use expanded and the human population grew. Emissions rose especially quickly during the twentieth century and after 1950, driven by greater electricity production, transport, manufacturing and cement production. Deforestation released additional emissions through burning and decomposition. It also removed vegetation that could absorb CO2CO_2.

Before widespread industrialization, the atmospheric concentration was about 280 parts per million. During the 2020s, it exceeded 420 parts per million—roughly a 50% increase. Concentration and annual emissions aren't the same: emissions are an input flow, whereas atmospheric CO2CO_2 is a storage. It accumulates when inputs exceed removal by oceans and terrestrial ecosystems.

Worked example: Calculate the percentage increase in atmospheric CO2CO_2 concentration using 280 parts per million as the initial value and 420 parts per million as the final value.

  1. Find the increase in concentration:

    420−280=140 ppm420 - 280 = 140\ \text{ppm}

  2. Divide the increase by the initial concentration and multiply by 100:

    Percentage increase=420−280280×100=50%\text{Percentage increase} = \frac{420 - 280}{280} \times 100 = 50\%

Answer

Answer: The increase from 280 to 420 parts per million is 50% of the initial concentration.

Worked example: In a hypothetical annual carbon budget, emissions add 10 Gt C yr−110\ \text{Gt C yr}^{-1} to the atmosphere, while oceans and terrestrial ecosystems remove 6 Gt C yr−16\ \text{Gt C yr}^{-1}. Calculate the net rate of change in atmospheric carbon storage. Here, Gt C means gigatonnes of carbon, not gigatonnes of CO2CO_2.

  1. Subtract the removal flow from the emissions flow:

    Net rate of storage change=emissions flow−removal flow\text{Net rate of storage change} = \text{emissions flow} - \text{removal flow}

  2. Substitute the hypothetical values:

    Net rate of storage change=10−6=+4 Gt C yr−1\text{Net rate of storage change} = 10 - 6 = +4\ \text{Gt C yr}^{-1}

Answer

Answer: Atmospheric carbon storage increases at 4 Gt C yr−14\ \text{Gt C yr}^{-1} because emissions exceed removals.

Common mistake: Falling annual emissions do not necessarily mean falling atmospheric CO2CO_2 concentration. If emissions still exceed removals, atmospheric storage continues to increase, even though emissions have fallen.

Reading the atmospheric record

The long-term atmospheric record shows an upward trend, along with a small annual oscillation caused mainly by seasonal plant growth and decay. This oscillation is particularly noticeable across the land-rich Northern Hemisphere. During the Northern Hemisphere growing season, plant uptake lowers atmospheric CO2CO_2; reduced winter uptake and continued decomposition contribute to its seasonal rise. For anthropogenic climate change, the long-term rise is what matters; the seasonal saw-tooth pattern doesn't cancel it.

Compare the long-term rise with the expanded seasonal pattern below.

The historical evidence strongly supports anthropogenic attribution. Natural carbon-cycle flows continue, but the timing and scale of the modern increase closely match industrial fossil-fuel use and land-use change.

6.2.3

EVIDENCE FROM CLIMATE PROXIES

Records of past climates

Natural archives provide evidence from before instrumental observations began.

Ice cores

An ice core is a cylindrical sample removed from an ice sheet or glacier whose layers preserve evidence of earlier atmospheric and climatic conditions. Scientists can analyse trapped air bubbles to find past concentrations of CO2CO_2 and other gases. Isotopic composition also helps them reconstruct temperature.

Example: In Antarctic ice cores, scientists measure past atmospheric CO2CO_2 in trapped air bubbles and use the isotopic composition of the ice to reconstruct past temperature. These are different measurements from the same archive.

Tree rings

A tree ring is an annual layer of woody growth whose width and density reflect environmental conditions during its formation. In places where temperature or moisture limits growth, wide rings may show relatively favourable years, while narrow rings suggest unfavourable ones. Ring growth also depends on tree age, disease and local competition, so the relationship must be calibrated against modern observations.

Example: In moisture-limited tree growth, wider rings can indicate wetter years and narrower rings can indicate drier years. Dated rings provide a year-by-year sequence, but the rainfall interpretation depends on calibration against modern observations.

Sediment cores

Deposited sediments are accumulated layers of mineral or organic material that preserve evidence of past environments. Pollen, shells, organic remains and sediment grain size can reveal the vegetation, temperature, water conditions or aridity present as each layer formed. Once the layers are dated, the evidence becomes a time series.

The three archives link sampled features to reconstructions of past conditions.

Correlation over glacial cycles

Records from approximately 800,000 years show repeated glacial–interglacial cycles. Atmospheric CO2CO_2 concentration and reconstructed global temperature generally rise and fall together. Warm periods coincide with relatively high CO2CO_2, whereas cold glacial periods coincide with lower CO2CO_2. This is a positive correlation: higher values of one variable tend to occur with higher values of the other.

To investigate this type of graph:

  • First identify repeated peaks and troughs.
  • Compare their timing and ranges.
  • Then compare the recent value with the earlier range.

In this record, modern CO2CO_2 lies above the concentrations recorded during previous cycles.

Correlation by itself doesn’t establish a one-way cause. Orbital forcing could have initiated past changes, with carbon-cycle feedback then amplifying them. However, laboratory physics, the atmospheric energy balance and modern emissions data provide an independent causal mechanism through which additional CO2CO_2 produces warming.

6.2.4

THE ENHANCED GREENHOUSE EFFECT

From emissions to climate change

The greenhouse effect is an atmospheric process in which greenhouse gases absorb and re-emit some outgoing long-wave radiation, keeping the lower atmosphere and surface warmer than they would otherwise be. This process is natural and essential.

The enhanced greenhouse effect is the additional warming caused when human activities increase atmospheric greenhouse-gas concentrations, so a larger proportion of outgoing long-wave radiation is retained within the lower atmosphere–surface system. Human activities release large quantities of carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide, as well as smaller quantities of other greenhouse gases.

Major sources of CO2CO_2 include fossil-fuel combustion, cement production and deforestation. Methane, CH4CH_4, comes from livestock digestion, flooded rice cultivation, landfill, fossil-fuel extraction and wetlands. Fertilized agricultural soils and manure management are strongly associated with nitrous oxide, N2ON_2O.

Global warming is the long-term increase in Earth's mean surface temperature caused predominantly in the modern period by the enhanced greenhouse effect. Climate change is the broader range of persistent changes in climatic conditions, including altered precipitation, circulation, extremes and sea level as well as warming.

The causal chain works like this: human activities increase greenhouse-gas emissions, causing atmospheric concentrations to rise. More outgoing long-wave radiation is then absorbed and re-emitted. The global energy balance gains energy, global temperature rises, and connected atmospheric, oceanic and ecological processes change.

This gives a careful answer to the attribution question. Natural influences still affect climate from year to year and across geological time. However, the rapid, sustained modern trend is primarily anthropogenic: observed warming matches human greenhouse forcing and cannot be reproduced adequately by natural drivers alone.

6.2.5

IMPACTS ON ECOSYSTEMS

Scale and type of impact

Climate change affects ecosystems at every scale, from individual sites to the global Earth system. A biome shift is a movement in the geographical distribution of a biome as climatic conditions suitable for it move to a different latitude or altitude. Because species move at different rates, whole communities may be reorganized instead of shifting together intact.

Coral bleaching and desertification are local impacts. During severe marine heatwaves, corals may expel their symbiotic algae. They then lose their colour and much of their energy supply. If bleaching is repeated or prolonged, corals may die and reef habitat can decline. Exceptional marine heat in the Florida Keys during 2023 caused widespread bleaching and led to the temporary removal of nursery corals. This shows a local ecosystem responding to a wider climatic trend.

Desertification is land degradation in drylands that reduces biological productivity through climatic variation and human activities. Greater evaporation and less reliable rainfall can worsen damage from vegetation clearance, overgrazing or unsuitable cultivation.

On a global scale, warming and freshwater released by melting land ice can change ocean density and circulation. Sea level rises as warming seawater expands and melting land-based ice adds water to the oceans. Coastal wetlands, mangroves and nesting beaches may disappear if they cannot migrate inland.

Productivity, biodiversity and resilience

Some cool or high-latitude regions may initially become more productive naturally. Warmer conditions can lengthen growing seasons, while higher CO2CO_2 can increase photosynthesis. The benefit depends on other conditions, though. Nutrient shortages, heat damage, drought, fire, pests and extreme weather may eventually outweigh it.

Resilience is the capacity of a system to resist disturbance, recover and retain its essential structure and functions. Biodiversity often strengthens ecosystem resilience because species respond differently to disturbance. If one species declines, another may continue to perform a similar function. Low genetic or species diversity and fragmented habitat leave fewer options for recovery, as do rapid change and repeated disturbance. Climate change can therefore reduce biodiversity, which then weakens resilience—a reinforcing effect.

Investigating evidence

Climate graphs from different locations can reveal shifts in seasonal temperature and precipitation, rather than just changes in annual means. Long-term records of atmospheric CO2CO_2 and temperature support anthropogenic warming. In ocean records, increasing dissolved CO2CO_2 is associated with declining pH and ocean acidification.

For a database investigation, select one ecosystem and one measurable response, such as annual heat stress and coral cover. Keep the location and time period consistent, then plot the variables and look for any lag or anomalous years. Check other possible influences, including storms, disease or local pollution. A relationship provides useful evidence, but these additional variables limit a simple causal claim.

6.2.6

IMPACTS ON HUMAN SOCIETIES

Climate change affects societies from the household and community level to national and international scales. However, exposure varies sharply, as does the ability to respond. Societal resilience is the capacity of a human community to anticipate, withstand, adapt to and recover from disturbance while maintaining essential functions.

Main areas of impact

  • Health: heatwaves cause more heat exhaustion, cardiovascular stress and deaths. Shifts in temperature and rainfall can change where disease vectors are found. Smoke, flooding, food insecurity and displacement add further health risks.
  • Water supply: drought and increased evaporation deplete surface-water and soil-moisture stores. As glaciers shrink, runoff may rise temporarily before dry-season supplies decline. Floodwater can also contaminate drinking water.
  • Agriculture: heat stress, drought, floods and changing pests can lower crop yields or livestock productivity. Cooler regions may benefit from longer growing seasons, though only where fertile soil, water and suitable infrastructure are available.
  • Infrastructure: coastal settlements face threats from sea-level rise and storm surges. Heat can damage roads, railways and power systems. Intense rainfall may overwhelm drainage and wastewater systems.

The 2022 floods in Pakistan show how these impacts connect. Extreme monsoon rainfall and glacier melt inundated settlements and farmland, damaged transport and health facilities, contaminated water supplies and displaced millions. Climate change wasn’t the only factor: land use, poverty, drainage and settlement patterns also shaped the outcome. Even so, warming increased the likelihood and intensity of extreme rainfall.

Why resilience differs

Wealth can pay for cooling, flood protection, insurance, healthcare and reconstruction. Adaptive capacity also rises with effective government, trusted warnings, education, social networks and diversified livelihoods. By contrast, poverty, marginalization, weak institutions, conflict, poor housing and reliance on climate-sensitive work reduce it.

Scale makes a difference. Even a wealthy country may have highly vulnerable neighbourhoods. Meanwhile, a lower-income community may draw on strong local knowledge and mutual support. Ahmedabad in India, for example, developed a heat action plan that uses forecasts, public warnings, healthcare preparation and access to cooling measures. This shows that governance and planning—not income alone—shape resilience.

Climate impacts can deepen existing socio-economic inequalities. People with the least secure housing, poorest health or least political influence often suffer the greatest harm and take the longest to recover.

6.2.7

SYSTEMS DIAGRAMS AND CLIMATE FEEDBACK

Representing cause and effect

In a systems diagram, boxes represent variables or storages, while arrows show causal relationships. A plus sign on an arrow shows that the variables change in the same direction. A minus sign shows that they change in opposite directions. The signs describe the relationship; they don’t indicate whether an outcome is desirable.

A positive feedback loop is a feedback process that amplifies an initial change and moves a system farther from its previous equilibrium. A negative feedback loop is a feedback process that counteracts an initial change and tends to stabilize a system.

Albedo and methane feedbacks

Albedo is the proportion of incoming solar radiation reflected by a surface. As warming melts snow and ice, darker land or water is exposed. Albedo falls, so more solar radiation is absorbed. Further warming follows, making this positive feedback.

Warming may also thaw permafrost and speed up anaerobic decomposition in waterlogged soils. This releases methane, strengthening greenhouse forcing. The additional warming causes more thaw. The timing and size of the feedback remain uncertain, but its direction is reinforcing.

Solar radiation and the global energy balance

The global energy balance is the relationship between incoming solar radiation and energy leaving Earth as reflected short-wave and emitted long-wave radiation. When this balance is disrupted for a sustained period, the amount of energy stored in the climate system changes.

More solar radiation can warm Earth. In response, the warmer surface emits more long-wave radiation to space, which opposes the initial warming. This is a negative radiative feedback. Solar variation may initiate change, with albedo and greenhouse-gas responses modifying it. However, recent solar variation alone cannot explain current warming.

Every intermediate link should appear when drawing a loop. In the ice–albedo loop, drawing a direct link from melting ice to warming leaves out the assessed mechanism: less ice lowers albedo, causing greater absorption of solar energy.

6.2.8

THE PLANETARY BOUNDARY FOR CLIMATE CHANGE

A planetary boundary is a scientifically proposed limit for an Earth-system process beyond which the risk of large-scale, abrupt or irreversible environmental change rises substantially. It isn’t a cliff edge where catastrophe suddenly becomes certain. Instead, it marks the point at which conditions move beyond a comparatively safe operating space.

Published evidence

The planetary-boundaries framework assesses climate change through indicators such as atmospheric CO2CO_2 concentration and changes in Earth's energy balance. The proposed boundary is 350 parts per million CO2CO_2, yet modern concentrations exceed 420 parts per million. For this reason, the framework’s 2023 update classified the climate boundary as transgressed.

Several independent observations support this finding. Global warming has continued, while glaciers and ice sheets have experienced widespread loss. Ocean heat content is increasing, mean sea level is rising, and heat extremes are becoming more frequent or intense. Climate-system change, then, isn’t identified from a single indicator.

Some uncertainty remains. Boundary values are estimates, not perfectly known thresholds, and impacts vary between regions. Passing a boundary also doesn’t prove that every tipping point has already been crossed. But uncertainty works both ways: some responses could happen earlier or faster than central estimates suggest.

Published evidence strongly supports the assertion that humanity has moved beyond the proposed safe boundary for climate change. Further action is still worthwhile. Every avoided increment of warming lowers additional risk and makes adaptation more feasible.

6.2.9

PERSPECTIVES ON CLIMATE CHANGE

A perspective is a viewpoint formed from a person's or group's values, knowledge, experiences and circumstances. It affects which evidence people trust, which risks they put first and which responses they see as acceptable.

Factors shaping perspectives

Direct experience of heat, flooding, crop loss or coastal erosion can make climate risk feel immediate. Other influences include:

  • Wealth and education.
  • Occupation and age.
  • Culture and political identity.
  • Place of residence and access to reliable media.

For example, a farmer who depends on seasonal rainfall may view risk differently from an urban employee whose work is less directly affected by weather.

Values also shape how people interpret climate change. Environmental perspectives differ in what they prioritize, which affects the responses they consider acceptable. These perspectives can overlap: a person may value ecosystem protection, human welfare and technological solutions together.

Example: A government proposes replacing a coal-fired power station. The table applies three environmental perspectives to this same decision; these are possible responses, not fixed positions held by everyone with that perspective.

PerspectiveValue prioritizedPossible preferred responseJustification
EcocentricEcosystem integrity and rapid emission reduction.Close the coal-fired station rapidly, reduce energy demand and replace remaining generation with renewables while minimizing ecological damage.Reducing fossil-fuel use limits climate pressures on ecosystems; replacement projects should also protect habitats.
AnthropocentricHuman welfare, balanced against economic costs.Replace the station while maintaining affordable, reliable electricity and supporting affected workers.Emissions reduction protects people, but the policy should also address employment and household energy costs.
TechnocentricConfidence in innovation, engineering and market mechanisms.Use engineered low-carbon generation and energy storage, supported by market incentives, to replace coal power.Technological development and incentives can reduce emissions while maintaining electricity supplies.

From perspective to societal response

Governments, businesses, scientists, Indigenous communities, campaigners and consumers may agree that climate change is occurring, yet disagree about:

  • Timing and responsibility for action.
  • Acceptable cost.
  • The balance between mitigation and adaptation.

Communities that depend on fossil fuels may fear unemployment caused by a rapid transition. Low-lying communities, however, may see delayed action as an immediate threat.

Behaviour is also affected by personal perspectives. Concern doesn’t automatically lead to action. Cost, convenience, infrastructure and the belief that individual choices are insignificant can create a gap between values and behaviour. On the other hand, personal action can influence social norms and political demand, even when its direct effect on emissions is small.

Different perspectives therefore shape responses to climate change. Conflict and misinformation can delay collective action. Inclusive decision-making, though, can produce fairer, more durable policies by recognizing different knowledge, values and vulnerabilities. A strong judgement separates disagreement over values and policy from the rejection of well-supported physical evidence.

Example: Discuss whether a coal-fired power station should close rapidly. A coal-dependent community may favour a slower closure because it values secure employment and local economic stability, and its circumstances include dependence on coal-related jobs. A low-lying community may demand rapid emissions reduction because it values safety and protection of homes, and its circumstances include exposure to flooding and sea-level rise. Both positions reflect legitimate concerns about human welfare, but they distribute the risks of delay differently. On balance, rapid mitigation is justified to limit climate risks, provided closure is accompanied by worker-transition support, such as retraining and investment in alternative employment; this addresses employment concerns without treating them as a reason for indefinite delay.

6.2.10

DIRECT MEASUREMENTS AND CLIMATE PROXIES

HL

Direct observations

A direct measurement is an observation of the climatic variable being studied using an instrument at the time it occurs. Weather stations and observatories measure temperature, precipitation, humidity, air pressure and wind. Observatories with long-running records also track greenhouse-gas concentrations.

Radar detects precipitation and follows its movement using reflected radio waves. Satellites repeatedly observe large areas, recording cloud, surface temperature, vegetation, ice cover, fires and land use. This coverage is especially useful where ground stations are sparse. However, satellite records are shorter and must be calibrated against surface observations.

Researchers must check long-term records for changes in instruments, observation times and the surroundings of each station. For instance, urban growth around a station may affect its local temperature record. Rather than accepting every reading unchanged, scientists homogenize the data and compare records from neighbouring stations.

Proxy evidence

A proxy measurement is an indirect indicator from which a past climatic variable is inferred after calibration. These proxies extend climate records beyond the instrumental period.

Ice cores preserve atmospheric gases along with stable oxygen-isotope ratios. Ratios involving 18O^{18}\text{O} and 16O^{16}\text{O} change with temperature-dependent evaporation and condensation, so they can be used to infer past temperatures. Trapped air bubbles provide samples of earlier atmospheric greenhouse-gas concentrations.

Dendrochronology is the dating and analysis of annual tree rings to reconstruct environmental change. Where temperature or moisture limits growth, ring width or density may indicate that variable. Pollen preserved in peat cores reveals earlier plant communities. Because plant species have characteristic climatic tolerances, shifts in pollen assemblages indicate climatic and land-use change.

Direct observations tend to offer greater precision and temporal resolution, but they cover a relatively short period. Proxies reach much further into the past, though they involve uncertainties in dating, calibration and interpretation. Climate models rely on both. Direct data describe and test recent behaviour, while proxies show whether models reproduce longer-term climatic variability.

6.2.11

GLOBAL CLIMATE MODELS AND HINDCASTING

HL

A global climate model is a mathematical representation of Earth's climate system that uses equations to simulate physical, chemical and biological processes and their interactions across a three-dimensional grid. Although models simplify reality, they do far more than plot trend lines.

Inputs, processes and outputs

  • Inputs include data on solar radiation, greenhouse-gas concentrations or emissions, aerosols, volcanic particles and land-use conditions.
  • Processes represented include atmospheric and ocean circulation, radiation transfer, cloud formation, ice melt, and exchanges of carbon, water and energy.
  • Outputs may include temperature, precipitation, sea ice, ocean circulation and sea level.

A model cannot directly calculate every process that occurs at a scale smaller than one grid cell, such as the formation of individual clouds. A parameterization is a simplified mathematical representation of processes too small to resolve explicitly. Models use parameterizations based on observations and theory. The range of outcomes partly reflects different parameter choices and assumptions about future human activity.

Example: Rather than simulating each individual cloud, a model can use a parameterization to estimate the average effect of clouds on radiation within a grid cell.

Validation through hindcasting

The IB syllabus describes hindcasting as running models backwards from the present time to check the validity of the model. Here, “backwards” means testing against past climate, rather than reversing the physical processes: the simulation runs forward through a historical period.

Hindcasting is a model-testing process in which a model is run from an earlier time towards the present and its simulated outputs are compared with observed conditions. Credibility increases when a model reproduces major past trends and spatial patterns, including responses to volcanic eruptions. When it fails to do so, researchers may need to revise its equations, parameters or input data.

Worked example: How could the 1991 Mount Pinatubo eruption be used to test a climate model through hindcasting?

  1. Supply the model with the historical volcanic-aerosol forcing associated with the eruption. These aerosols reduced the solar energy reaching Earth's surface.
  2. Run the simulation forward through the following years to calculate the temperature response.
  3. Compare the simulated cooling with observed temperature records. Check both the magnitude of the cooling and its timing, rather than simply whether the model produces any cooling.
  4. Assess whether the model reproduces the observed temporary cooling and subsequent recovery as the volcanic-aerosol influence declined.
Answer

Answer: Agreement in the magnitude and timing of cooling after the 1991 Mount Pinatubo eruption supports the model's response to volcanic-aerosol forcing. It does not validate every regional projection or every response to other forcings.

Hindcasting tests a model; it doesn’t prove that every future prediction will be correct. For example, a model may reproduce the global mean but still perform poorly when simulating local rainfall. Future human emissions also have no exact historical equivalent.

Uncertainty

Sources of uncertainty include:

  • Inputs, especially proxy reconstructions and future emissions.
  • Model structure and parameterization.
  • Natural variability, which can affect when regional changes occur.

Scientists therefore compare several models and scenarios. Agreement between them raises confidence, while the spread of results shows a range of possible outcomes rather than a failure to understand climate.

6.2.12

CLIMATE-MODEL SCENARIOS

HL

A climate scenario is a coherent set of assumptions about future drivers used to explore a possible climate outcome. It does not claim that a particular future is certain. Different scenarios may use different assumptions about greenhouse-gas emissions, land use, population, energy systems and climate policy.

When models run under lower-emission scenarios, they generally project less warming and sea-level rise than under high-emission scenarios. These differences grow later in the century as greenhouse gases and heat accumulate over time.

Interpreting scenario data

Most scenario graphs show a central line surrounded by an uncertainty range. Compare the direction, magnitude and timing of change. Look for the point when the ranges separate, but don’t treat the upper and lower bounds as impossible limits. Check the stated range definition: bounds do not automatically represent a particular probability. Overlapping ranges indicate that the outcomes represented by the scenarios are not clearly separated at that time.

This schematic shows how central estimates can differ while uncertainty ranges overlap.

Exam tip: State the reference level or baseline period before comparing changes. Quantify the difference at the same date, and use “projects” rather than “will” when describing a scenario outcome.

Worked example: Use an illustrative sea-level dataset to compare the lower- and higher-emission pathways by 2100. These values are illustrative, not cited outputs from named scenarios; sea-level rise is measured relative to 2020.

Illustrative pathwaySea-level rise by 2100 relative to 2020 / m\text{m}
Lower-emission0.32
Higher-emission0.78
  1. Subtract the lower-emission value from the higher-emission value:

    Difference=0.78 m−0.32 m=0.46 m\text{Difference} = 0.78\ \text{m} - 0.32\ \text{m} = 0.46\ \text{m}

Answer

Answer: By 2100, the illustrative higher-emission pathway projects 0.46 m0.46\ \text{m} more sea-level rise than the lower-emission pathway, relative to 2020. Neither pathway is a certain prediction.

Why sea-level rise can continue

Sea level responds slowly because oceans retain heat, while ice sheets take time to adjust. Reducing positive greenhouse-gas emissions need not stop atmospheric concentrations from increasing: concentrations can continue to grow while additions exceed removals. Stabilizing concentrations is therefore different from simply reducing emissions. Even after global temperature stabilizes, continuing ocean and ice-sheet adjustment can sustain sea-level rise.

Local sea-level change can also differ from the global mean due to:

  • Ocean circulation.
  • Gravitational effects of ice loss.
  • Vertical land movement and coastal subsidence.

Regional patterns and uncertainty

Temperature patterns aren’t the same everywhere. Land usually warms faster than ocean, and high northern latitudes warm particularly rapidly.

Precipitation projections show less uniformity:

  • Warmer air can hold more water vapour, which intensifies heavy rainfall in some places.
  • Elsewhere, altered circulation and greater evaporation increase drying.

Local projections are more uncertain than the global temperature trend because regional precipitation and circulation are difficult to resolve. Comparing scenarios is still useful: it reveals which impacts depend strongly on future human choices and which changes are already difficult to avoid.

6.2.13

CRITICAL THRESHOLDS AND NEW EQUILIBRIA

HL

A critical threshold is a boundary beyond which a small additional pressure can produce a disproportionately large change in a system's state. A tipping point is a critical threshold at which self-reinforcing processes can commit a system to a substantially different state. After that, a new equilibrium may form around different conditions.

Thresholds occur both in the global climate system and in local ecosystems. Global thresholds are particularly concerning: change may be rapid and difficult to anticipate. It may also be irreversible on human timescales, with catastrophic consequences for exposed societies or ecosystems.

Example: Amazon rainforest–Cerrado transition

The Amazon recycles moisture through evapotranspiration. Trees release water vapour that supports regional rainfall; this rainfall then maintains forest growth. Warming, drought and deforestation reduce tree cover and evapotranspiration. As rainfall declines, the dry season lengthens. Fire and tree mortality increase, causing still more forest loss.

Through this positive feedback, parts of the system may cross a threshold from humid rainforest towards a more open, seasonally dry vegetation state resembling the Cerrado. Such a change would reduce biodiversity and carbon storage. It could also release additional CO2CO_2, reinforcing global warming. The exact location of the threshold remains uncertain because it depends on warming, deforestation, fire, rainfall and ecological adaptation.

Other possible thresholds include destabilization of Antarctic ice sheets and slowing of Atlantic thermohaline circulation. Ice-sheet loss can become self-sustaining when retreat exposes thicker ice to warm ocean water or lowers the ice surface into warmer air. Atlantic circulation may weaken when warming and freshwater input reduce the density of North Atlantic surface water, disrupting sinking and heat transport.

Climate models identify risks and ranges, not exact countdown points. Uncertainty about the threshold doesn’t show that the risk is absent. Instead, it gives a reason to avoid pressures that could push the system into a new equilibrium.

6.2.14

TIPPING CASCADES

HL

A tipping cascade is a sequence of interacting threshold changes in which crossing one tipping point increases the likelihood of crossing one or more others. What makes it a cascade is the interaction, not simply the presence of several separate tipping points.

Individual tipping elements may be biotic, involving living organisms or ecological processes, or abiotic, involving non-living physical components. Some combine both. Amazon forest dieback is strongly biotic, though it also depends on abiotic rainfall and temperature. Ice-sheet loss and changes in ocean circulation are predominantly abiotic.

How tipping elements can interact

As Greenland loses ice, freshwater enters the North Atlantic. This may weaken Atlantic overturning circulation and change heat and rainfall patterns. Shifts in tropical rainfall could place the Amazon under greater drought stress, encouraging fire and forest loss. With less carbon stored in the forest, atmospheric CO2CO_2 rises. The resulting warming then accelerates Greenland and Antarctic ice loss.

The proposed links don’t all have the same strength or certainty. Some interactions reinforce each other, while others oppose one another or take effect only after long time lags. With two or more tipping points involved, the scale and pace of future climate change become especially uncertain. If abrupt interactions occur, standard projections based on gradual responses may underestimate the risk.

Uncertainty does not mean that every outcome is equally probable. Models and observations can identify the more credible links, as can palaeoclimate evidence. Even so, exact thresholds and timings remain difficult to determine. The possibility of cascades supports a precautionary approach because preventing the first threshold crossing may avoid several subsequent changes.

6.2.15

RESPONSIBILITY, VULNERABILITY AND CLIMATE JUSTICE

HL

Unequal responsibility and vulnerability

Countries differ in their responsibility for climate change, meaning their contribution to the emissions driving it. They also differ in vulnerability, meaning their susceptibility to harm, shaped by exposure to hazards, sensitivity and capacity to adapt. The least responsible countries are often among the most vulnerable, creating issues of equity.

Comparing responsibility

No single emissions measure gives a complete picture. Distinguish the time period being measured from whether emissions are expressed per country or per person.

MeasureWhat it showsLimitation when assigning responsibility
Current emission rateEmissions released per year; identifies today's major emittersExcludes earlier contributions
Cumulative emissionsTotal emissions since the start of the Industrial RevolutionDoes not show current progress in reducing emissions
Emissions per countryA country's total contribution over the stated periodLarge populations can produce high totals despite low individual emissions
Emissions per personCountry emissions divided by populationAn average conceals inequalities within the country

Example: China has higher current annual territorial CO2CO_2 emissions than the United States, but the United States has contributed more cumulative CO2CO_2 since industrialization. Qatar has high emissions per person despite a much smaller national total. Rankings therefore depend on the measure used.

Where vulnerability is greatest

Particularly vulnerable countries include:

  • Low-lying island states such as Tuvalu, where sea-level rise increases coastal flooding, erosion and saltwater intrusion into freshwater supplies.
  • Bangladesh, where densely populated, low-lying coastal areas face flooding and salinization of soils and water.
  • Chad and other low-income countries exposed to drought and extreme heat, where reliance on rain-fed farming and limited financial resources increase vulnerability.

Exposure alone does not determine outcomes. Wealth, effective institutions and access to technology can improve a country's capacity to protect people and recover from damage.

Equity and political implications

Climate justice means addressing climate change in ways that distribute responsibilities, costs and protection fairly. Greater historical emissions strengthen claims that a country bears greater responsibility. Greater responsibility strengthens demands for financial support to vulnerable countries. High vulnerability also strengthens these demands, especially where national emissions have been very low.

Responsibility and vulnerability provide different grounds for demands for climate finance.

This creates political disagreement over who should pay and how much. Vulnerable countries argue for support with adaptation and with loss and damage, the harms caused by climate impacts. Economic implications include reconstruction costs, lost livelihoods and pressure on public budgets. Equity does not necessarily mean equal payments: contributions may instead reflect historical responsibility and ability to pay.

Exam tip: When comparing countries, specify whether evidence concerns current or cumulative emissions, and national or per-person emissions. Explain the mismatch between responsibility and vulnerability rather than assuming that the largest current emitter is responsible for all historical warming.

Were those notes helpful?

6.1 Introduction to the atmosphere

6.3 Climate change—mitigation and adaptation