13 sections · ~23 min read
This content can't be printed from the browser. Use Export PDF with Pro for an offline copy.
IB Syllabus Requirements for Human impact on biodiversity
3.2.1
Biological diversity is being adversely affected by both direct and indirect influences
3.2.2
Most ecosystems are subject to multiple human impacts
3.2.3
Invasive alien species can reduce local biodiversity
3.2.4
Global conservation status and the IUCN Red List
3.2.1
BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY IS BEING ADVERSELY AFFECTED BY BOTH DIRECT AND INDIRECT INFLUENCES
The central question here goes beyond why biodiversity is declining. We need to follow each cause through ecological systems, then examine how it affects food, income, culture, health and security in societal systems.
A direct threat is a human influence that harms organisms by immediately removing, capturing or killing them. Examples include poaching and the illegal pet trade, as well as overharvesting, where organisms are removed faster than their populations can replace them. Such pressures reduce abundance and remove breeding adults. They can also change a population’s age or sex structure. When killing is selective, it may favour particular inherited traits, so human activity can change the population itself while shrinking it.
Exam tip: “Poaching reduces biodiversity” states an effect but does not explain how it occurs. A stronger response is: “Poaching removes breeding adults, reducing reproduction and recruitment of young; if births no longer replace losses, the population declines.” An “explain” response needs a causal link, not just a list of threats.
An indirect threat is a human influence that harms organisms by changing environmental conditions. These threats include:
Different forms of habitat change need to be kept separate. Habitat fragmentation is a process in which a continuous habitat is divided into smaller, isolated patches. This leaves smaller populations, restricts movement and gene flow, and makes edge effects more important. Habitat degradation is a reduction in the quality or ecological complexity of a habitat without necessarily removing it completely. A forest may remain visible on a map even after it has lost old trees, nesting sites and food sources.
Example: Bornean orangutans face several distinct forms of habitat change. Clearing forest for oil palm plantations causes habitat loss; roads dividing the remaining forest cause fragmentation; selective logging can degrade retained forest by removing trees used for food and nesting. Isolated patches restrict movement between orangutan populations, reducing opportunities to find mates and breed across patches, so gene flow is reduced. Conversion to plantations can generate income for producers and employment for workers. The societal trade-off is between these economic benefits and retaining forest habitat that supports orangutans and forest-dependent livelihoods.
Human population growth and rising consumption intensify both categories of threat because they increase demand for:
Even so, biodiversity loss doesn’t occur at the same rate in every country. Ecosystems, monitoring capacity, environmental values, protection policies and levels of economic development all differ.
3.2.2
MOST ECOSYSTEMS ARE SUBJECT TO MULTIPLE HUMAN IMPACTS
Most ecosystems face several pressures at the same time, and these are increasing. Together, their impact may be greater than the separate effects simply added up. Warming and altered rainfall, for example, can reduce food availability and reproductive success. The population becomes smaller, leaving it less able to withstand disease, harvesting or competition from an introduced species.
Example: On the Great Barrier Reef, heat stress causes coral bleaching, while nutrient pollution promotes algal growth and overfishing removes herbivores that graze algae. Their combined effects can exceed independent effects because algae occupy space needed for coral recruitment, hindering recovery after bleaching rather than simply adding a separate disturbance.
Ecological resilience is the capacity of an ecological system to resist disturbance or recover while retaining its main structure and functions. Climate stress, habitat fragmentation or pollution can weaken this capacity. With lower resilience, a pressure that was once tolerable may trigger rapid decline. Studying one threat on its own can therefore underestimate the actual risk.
A practical investigation could compare species diversity at different distances from a source of human interference, such as a footpath, road edge or managed shoreline. Lay a transect perpendicular to the boundary, crossing the expected disturbance gradient. Then place quadrats at fixed or randomly selected distances. Identify the species present and record abundance using a consistent method.
Alternatively, establish transects and sample randomly within them before and after a human activity. The same locations should be revisited in the same season, using the same quadrat size, sampling effort and identification method. Replication matters because a single transect might cross an unrepresentative patch.
Distance from the interference or time relative to the activity could be the independent variable. Species diversity is the dependent measure, supported by records of richness and abundance. Where possible, relevant environmental variables—light, soil moisture, trampling intensity or water quality—should also be recorded. For a stronger before-and-after comparison, include a nearby unaffected control site. This helps separate the effect of the activity from weather, seasonal change and natural spatial variation. Remember: a pattern along a transect shows an association; a causal conclusion needs control of plausible alternative explanations.
Worked example: Plan a replicated investigation of plant diversity with distance from a footpath, and interpret illustrative abundance observations.
| Distance / | A | B | C | Species richness |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 9 | 1 | 0 | 2 |
| 10 | 5 | 3 | 2 | 3 |
| 20 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 |
Answer: The independent variable is distance from the footpath in metres. The subset suggests greater diversity farther away: richness rises from 2 to 3 species, and abundances become more even. Replicate observations are needed to assess whether this pattern is consistent.
3.2.3
INVASIVE ALIEN SPECIES CAN REDUCE LOCAL BIODIVERSITY
An alien species is one introduced by human activity beyond its natural geographic range. An invasive alien species is an alien species that becomes established, spreads and reduces local biodiversity. However, alien species aren’t necessarily invasive. Many introduced species either fail to survive or cause little ecological harm.
Some introductions are deliberate, including ornamental plants, game animals and biological-control organisms. Others happen accidentally through ballast water, cargo, soil, packaging, aquaculture escapes or transport on vehicles. A lag phase often follows arrival. Rapid, approximately exponential growth is more likely if the species reproduces quickly, eats a broad diet, disperses effectively and finds abundant resources. Having few predators, parasites or diseases in the new ecosystem also helps. In disturbed habitats, competition may be especially weak and many opportunities remain vacant.
An invasive species can reduce local biodiversity by:
After the Second World War, the brown tree snake reached Guam, probably concealed in military cargo from its native range in the western Pacific. Its population spread rapidly because prey was abundant, conditions were warm and the snake could climb effectively. It also faced few predators. Predation led to severe declines and local losses among native forest birds, disrupting processes such as seed dispersal.
Management includes cargo inspection, snake-proof barriers, traps, detector dogs and the aerial delivery of toxic baits in selected areas. These methods reduce snake numbers near ports, conservation sites and transport routes, but island-wide eradication hasn’t been achieved. This case shows why prevention and early eradication are generally cheaper and more effective than trying to control a species once it is widely established.
3.2.4
GLOBAL CONSERVATION STATUS AND THE IUCN RED LIST
The International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) is an international membership organization. It assesses biodiversity and supports conservation policy and action. Its IUCN Red List is a global information system that publishes assessments of species’ extinction risk. A species’ conservation status classifies its assessed risk of extinction.
Rather than judging a species by how rare or attractive it seems, the IUCN uses published quantitative criteria backed by data. An assessment considers:
Worked example: A hypothetical species declines from 10,000 to 4,000 mature individuals over ten years or three generations, whichever is longer. Calculate the percentage reduction and interpret it using IUCN Criterion A2. Assume that the conditions for A2 are satisfied: this is a past reduction whose causes may not have ceased, may not be understood or may not be reversible.
Calculate the loss of mature individuals:
Divide the loss by the initial population and multiply by 100:
Compare the reduction with the Endangered threshold under A2: a reduction of at least 50% over the assessment period.
Answer: The population declined by 60%, meeting the Endangered reduction threshold under Criterion A2 when its conditions are satisfied. This calculation illustrates one criterion, not a complete assessment of the species.
The principal sequence starts with least concern (LC), followed by near threatened (NT), vulnerable (VU), endangered (EN) and critically endangered (CR), then extinct in the wild (EW) and extinct (EX).
Threatened species comprise vulnerable (VU), endangered (EN) and critically endangered (CR).
Data deficient (DD) means there isn’t enough evidence to assign an extinction risk. Not evaluated (NE) means that no assessment has yet been completed.
Common mistake: DD is not evidence of low risk: insufficient information does not mean a species is safe. EW is not the same as EX: a species extinct in the wild still survives in captivity, cultivation or as a naturalized population outside its past range, whereas an extinct species has no surviving individuals.
Assessments need regular updates because threats and population trends change. Precision is limited by uneven surveying, uncertain population estimates, inaccessible habitats and taxonomic gaps. Even with these limits, a transparent common system makes global comparison and priority-setting far more defensible.
3.2.5
CONSERVATION STATUS INFORMS PRIORITIES AND MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES
A global conservation status makes vulnerability visible and allows comparisons. It can bring attention to neglected species and steer research, funding and protected-area planning. Red List status also informs trade controls and helps managers select measures such as habitat restoration, captive breeding, invasive-species control or harvest restrictions.
A non-governmental organization (NGO) operates independently of direct government control. It pursues social or environmental objectives rather than exercising state authority. Decision-makers use Red List information from different perspectives:
Citizen science can fill geographical and seasonal gaps in biodiversity records, though participation levels and identification skills vary. Inequality affects whose knowledge gets recorded. Communities with limited access to education, technology, transport or scientific institutions may possess valuable local knowledge but remain under-represented in formal databases and decisions. Conservation priorities should combine global status with ecological role, feasibility, cost and local knowledge, while also considering the rights and needs of affected people.
Example: The vaquita case developed in 3.2.6 shows how status informs action. Its Critically Endangered status signals an urgent need to reduce deaths from entanglement in gillnets. Mexico’s government has restricted gillnet use in vaquita habitat, while NGOs support monitoring and net removal. However, restrictions affect fishers who depend on gillnet fishing for their livelihoods, so management must also consider viable alternative fishing methods and income sources. Red List status identifies extinction risk; it does not itself impose legal protection. Governments must establish and enforce restrictions, and the wider strategy must address the threat, practical feasibility and local livelihood concerns rather than relying on status alone.
3.2.6
NAMED SPECIES WITH CONTRASTING CONSERVATION OUTCOMES
The dodo was a flightless bird found only on Mauritius. After people settled there, hunting helped drive its decline. Introduced pigs, rats and other animals disturbed nests, ate eggs and altered the bird’s forest habitat. It was extinct by the late seventeenth century. No timely conservation programme was put in place, so the response failed completely.
Its disappearance removed a large terrestrial fruit-eater and probably altered some seed-dispersal relationships, though the scale of these effects remains uncertain. For society, the dodo became an enduring warning about human-caused extinction. It later became part of Mauritius’s cultural identity, but that symbolic value can’t replace the ecological functions that were lost.
The vaquita is a small porpoise found only in the northern Gulf of California, Mexico. Its main threat is entanglement and drowning in gillnets, particularly those set illegally for totoaba. Because the species has a tiny geographic range and an extremely small population, every additional death poses a greater danger.
Conservation measures have included a gillnet exclusion zone, bans on high-risk nets, patrols and net removal. There have also been attempts to give fishers safer gear and alternative livelihoods. However, enforcement and livelihood support haven’t stopped illegal fishing, so the strategy has yet to secure a recovery. If the vaquita disappears, the gulf food web will lose a native predator. Fishing restrictions can also reduce local incomes and cause conflict unless fishers help design the alternatives and share their benefits.
Commercial whaling reduced many humpback whale populations to very low levels. International restrictions on commercial whaling and national protection helped many populations recover substantially, supported by sanctuaries, monitoring and action to reduce ship strikes and entanglement. The species is now assessed globally as least concern. Some populations remain vulnerable, however, and still need continued protection.
Recovery brings back ecological functions. Whales move nutrients through feeding, migration and waste release, while their carcasses provide food for deep-sea food webs. Whale watching offers income and cultural benefits too, although poorly managed tourism can disturb the animals. The intervention has been successful, but some populations and threats remain unresolved.
3.2.7
THE TRAGEDY OF THE COMMONS
The tragedy of the commons describes how human activity can overexploit shared natural resources when individual self-interest conflicts with the shared benefits of sustainable development. The “commons” is the shared resource or environment. Tragedy is a possible outcome, not an unavoidable law.
With unrestricted access, each user gains most of the immediate benefit from taking one more unit of a resource, but the environmental cost is spread across everyone. As these individually rational choices accumulate, the resource may fall below a sustainable level. The problem becomes more severe when ownership is weak, resources are mobile, damage is delayed, outcomes are uncertain or agreements are difficult to enforce.
Pacific bluefin tuna move across national jurisdictions and the high seas. As a result, no single fishing fleet owns the stock, and each fleet has an incentive to catch the fish before its competitors do. Excessive harvesting reduces spawning biomass and genetic diversity, especially when juveniles are caught before they reproduce. It also alters pelagic food webs. International catch limits and size controls can slow this race to fish, alongside monitoring and allocation agreements. However, these measures rely on credible data and cooperation.
The Gulf is also used as a shared waste sink. Nutrients from many farms, settlements and industries travel through the Mississippi basin. Individual sources benefit from cheap production or disposal, while the downstream costs are shared. Eutrophication and decomposition then produce seasonal low-oxygen water. This reduces benthic biodiversity and affects fisheries. Action is needed across the basin through nutrient standards, wetland restoration, farm incentives and monitoring, since one downstream community cannot solve an upstream problem involving many users.
Commons can be managed successfully when limits are enforceable, access rights are agreed and resource users take part. Monitoring and sanctions also matter. Private ownership or centralized regulation may help in some situations, but neither guarantees fairness or sustainability.
3.2.8
BIODIVERSITY HOTSPOTS ARE THREATENED BY HABITAT DESTRUCTION
A biodiversity hotspot is a geographic region with exceptional concentrations of endemic species that has also suffered severe habitat loss. An endemic species is restricted to a particular geographical area. To qualify formally as a hotspot, a region must meet both criteria:
Biodiversity isn’t spread evenly across the planet, so protecting a relatively small tropical area may prevent more global extinctions than protecting the same area somewhere with fewer endemic species.
Tropical biomes matter especially because their warm, wet conditions support high productivity and complex habitats, with long periods of speciation. Yet many tropical species have narrow ranges. Clearing a single forest or island can therefore remove a large share of their total habitat. Roads, logging, mining, dams and agricultural expansion destroy habitat while fragmenting what survives.
Many hotspots lie in developing countries, where limited public finance may restrict conservation. Other pressures include:
Opportunity costs are uneven too: local communities may have to give up land or resources, while global society gains much of the benefit through climate regulation and species persistence.
Example: The Sundaland hotspot includes Borneo and Sumatra, where logging and the expansion of oil-palm plantations have caused forest habitat loss and fragmentation. Endemic biodiversity at risk includes the Bornean orangutan, whose natural range is restricted to Borneo. Logging and oil-palm production provide employment and export revenue, creating economic incentives to convert forest. Protecting remaining habitat can therefore impose opportunity costs on local people: they may lose potential plantation jobs or income from farming and timber harvesting. Restrictions on forest access may also reduce access to resources used for livelihoods, while the benefits of preventing extinctions are shared globally.
This uneven distribution affects how conservation works in practice. International funding, technology transfer and fair trade arrangements can help share the costs. Effective conservation must still support livelihoods and respect local decision-making. Drawing a protected-area boundary without resources, legitimacy or alternatives may simply move exploitation elsewhere rather than stop it.
3.2.9
KEY BIODIVERSITY AREAS ARE INTERNATIONAL CONSERVATION PRIORITIES
A key biodiversity area (KBA) is a site that makes a significant contribution to the global persistence of biodiversity. It may contain threatened or geographically restricted biodiversity, support important ecological processes, or include ecosystems at risk of collapse. KBAs are identified using international criteria, but designation alone does not create legal protection.
The Lake Alaotra wetland complex has international importance because of its endemic freshwater and marsh biodiversity. Around the lake, reed and papyrus habitat supports the critically endangered Alaotran gentle lemur, a species restricted to this area. Both the lemur and the wetland's functioning face several threats: marsh burning and conversion, sedimentation, invasive species and intensive fishing. Protecting the site safeguards biodiversity that cannot simply be conserved elsewhere.
Extensive Afroalpine habitat occurs in the Bale Mountains, along with species that have very restricted distributions. These include the endangered Ethiopian wolf and the mountain nyala. The highlands also regulate water supplies that feed surrounding river basins. Agricultural expansion, livestock pressure, disease transmission from domestic dogs and habitat fragmentation threaten both species and ecosystem processes. Conservation protects globally irreplaceable species as well as a high-altitude ecosystem vulnerable to degradation and climate change.
Together, these sites show why prioritization matters. Conservation funds are limited, so international importance, irreplaceability and risk can identify places where failure would cause an especially large global loss. However, prioritization shouldn't lead to the neglect of ordinary ecosystems. They still provide connectivity and services, and they may become future refuges.
3.2.10
CONFLICT WITHIN KEY BIODIVERSITY AREAS
In KBAs, exploitation means using natural resources for economic or material benefit. Sustainable development meets present needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. Conservation can limit immediate resource use to protect species, habitats and ecological processes. Conflict often follows because the costs and benefits affect different people and operate over different timescales.
Around Lake Alaotra, local livelihoods and the national food supply rely on rice farming, fishing and wetland products. Expanding rice fields may provide short-term income and food security. However, drainage, burning and land conversion destroy the marsh habitat needed by endemic species. Sediment inputs and unsustainable fishing can also damage the lake. Strict exclusion could protect the habitat, but it may disadvantage households that depend directly on the wetland, leading to resistance or illegal use.
A more sustainable approach could use community-managed marsh zones alongside protected core habitat. It would also include agreed fishing seasons and gear, restoration, fire management, and higher yields on existing farmland instead of continual expansion. Ecotourism or conservation-linked payments may provide alternative sources of income, but the benefits must reach local residents. A durable compromise doesn’t mean “no development”. It means keeping development within ecological limits and negotiating it with the people who bear its costs.
3.2.11
TRADITIONAL INDIGENOUS APPROACHES TO LAND MANAGEMENT
Traditional indigenous land management often draws on detailed, place-based knowledge. Seasonal limits, collective rules and responsibility across generations can make it more sustainable. Still, no traditional practice is automatically sustainable or fixed in the past. Outcomes depend on population, access to land and changing environmental conditions.
While travelling and gathering food, Martu communities in the Western Desert of Australia use small, carefully timed fires. These burns produce patches of vegetation at different stages of recovery, rather than leaving one continuous area of old fuel. The resulting mosaic can lower the likelihood of very large, intense wildfires. It also creates varied habitats and supports customary food collection.
Several connected pressures affect the practice:
Some threats come from outside communities, including climate change and government policy. Others develop within communities as economic opportunities and aspirations change. Supporting the practice requires indigenous authority and secure access, along with paid ranger programmes and room for knowledge to adapt. It shouldn’t be preserved as a museum piece while communities are denied the right to develop.
3.2.12
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE IN BIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION
Environmental justice requires environmental benefits and burdens to be shared fairly. It also requires meaningful participation in decision-making and recognition of different communities, rights and knowledge. Conservation may protect biodiversity yet remain unjust when politically weak people bear the costs but receive little benefit.
Biodiversity-rich areas can also be homelands for indigenous or marginalized communities, as well as sources of food, water, medicine, identity and income. Creating a protected area through forced relocation may cut off access to these essential resources. Low-income communities may struggle to challenge such decisions because they lack legal representation, political influence or information.
The Sengwer people of Kenya’s Embobut Forest show this tension. Authorities have used forest protection and watershed conservation to justify evictions and restrictions. Sengwer representatives, however, have argued for ancestral land rights and community-led stewardship. Conserving the forest is an ecological aim, but consent, compensation and cultural loss must still be assessed, along with who holds authority over the land.
A just conservation process involves affected people from the beginning. It recognizes customary tenure and ecological knowledge, makes evidence and appeal procedures accessible, and shares employment or tourism income fairly. If restrictions are genuinely necessary, compensation and alternative livelihoods must be adequate and agreed rather than imposed.
Some trade-offs remain difficult. Local resource use isn’t always sustainable, while governments still have a responsibility to prevent extinction. Sound judgement therefore rejects both extremes: biodiversity doesn’t always override human rights, and a claimed livelihood doesn’t automatically override ecological limits. Effective conservation must pursue ecological persistence alongside procedural, distributive and recognitional justice. Ignoring either side weakens legitimacy and long-term success.
3.2.13
THE PLANETARY BOUNDARY “LOSS OF BIOSPHERE INTEGRITY” INDICATES THAT SPECIES EXTINCTIONS HAVE ALREADY CROSSED A CRITICAL THRESHOLD
Biosphere integrity is the maintenance of biological diversity and the ecological functions that sustain the biosphere. A planetary boundary defines a limit to human disturbance within which the Earth system is expected to remain relatively stable. The IB syllabus states that species extinctions have already crossed a critical threshold for the boundary “loss of biosphere integrity”. This means that extinction rates indicate disruption beyond the proposed safe operating space, not that all ecosystems have already collapsed.
Human-driven species extinctions remove organisms and their ecological roles. Loss of ecological roles can disrupt food webs and nutrient cycling. These disruptions can reduce resilience, the capacity of a system to recover from disturbance while maintaining its functions. Reduced resilience makes further disturbances more likely to trigger major ecosystem change.
The chain shows how extinctions can weaken ecosystem stability.
A tipping point is a threshold beyond which a small additional disturbance can cause a large, potentially irreversible change in a system. It is distinct from a planetary boundary:
| Concept | Meaning for biodiversity loss |
|---|---|
| Crossing a planetary boundary | Human pressure has exceeded a proposed safe limit, increasing the risk of destabilization. |
| Crossing a tipping point | A system shifts into a different state, potentially maintained by reinforcing feedbacks. |
Example: In tropical forests, seed-dispersing animals move seeds away from parent trees. Their loss can reduce regeneration of some tree species and change forest composition. If forest degradation reduces carbon storage, this can contribute to warming, which can further stress forests. This illustrates a possible reinforcing feedback, rather than proof that a global tipping point has occurred.
The claim that extinctions could trigger a tipping point in the whole Earth system is plausible because ecosystems are interconnected through carbon, water and nutrient cycles. Changes across many ecosystems could reinforce one another. However, evidence of local ecosystem disruption does not establish a single global tipping threshold. Outcomes depend on which species disappear, their ecological roles and whether other species can maintain those functions. Complex interactions make the timing and scale of change uncertain.
Exam tip: Distinguish an already-crossed planetary boundary from a possible future Earth-system tipping point. Support the claim with a mechanism linking extinction to lost functions and feedbacks, then acknowledge uncertainty. Uncertainty about the exact tipping point does not mean biodiversity loss is safe.