Clastify logo
Subjects
Features
Review
HOT Save 10%
Tutoring
Log in

HL.c Environmental ethics

Practice exam-style IB ESS questions for Environmental ethics, aligned with the syllabus and grouped by topic.

Verified by Veronica
Verified by Veronica
Paper
Difficulty
Status
Level

This content can't be printed from the browser. Use Export PDF with Pro for an offline copy.

Question 1
HL • Paper 2
Easy
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Easy
Calculator Permitted

A

the term ethics.

[1]
B

the term ethical code.

[1]
Question 2
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

A

why environmental ethics became prominent during the 1960s and 1970s.

[3]
Question 3
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

The figure summarizes three responses to a proposal to clear part of a forest for mineral extraction.

A

the environmental worldview represented by each of pathways A, B and C.

[3]
B

why people accepting the same scientific evidence about the forest may support different decisions.

[1]
Question 4
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

A coastal mangrove provides nursery habitat for fish, reduces erosion and supports a complex community of organisms.

A

between the instrumental and intrinsic value of the mangrove.

[4]

Build a Practice Exam — ESS HL

Test your knowledge with a custom paper containing questions from selected topics.

Practice exam question preview
Practice exams dashboard preview
Question 5
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

Two organizations support the creation of a coral reef reserve. Organization X wishes to preserve the reef as a living community. Organization Y wishes to maintain fisheries, coastal protection and tourism income.

A

what this example demonstrates about intrinsic and instrumental value.

[3]
Question 6
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

A land manager voluntarily prevents machinery from entering a nesting site, although no law requires this and using the site would increase profit.

A

how this decision could be supported using virtue ethics.

[2]
Question 7
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

A speaker argues: “This mosquito is native and therefore natural, so controlling it can never be ethically justified,” although it transmits a serious disease.

A

why this argument is an appeal to nature fallacy.

[3]
Question 8
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

A

how assigning moral standing to future generations may affect a present decision to extract a non-renewable resource.

[3]

Build a Practice Exam — ESS HL

Test your knowledge with a custom paper containing questions from selected topics.

Practice exam question preview
Practice exams dashboard preview
Question 9
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

A proposed coastal barrier is expected to reduce flooding of a town but may cause the loss of salt-marsh habitat. Both effects are uncertain and may occur over several decades.

A

how a consequentialist could judge whether constructing the barrier is morally acceptable.

[3]
Question 10
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

A hydroelectric dam would provide electricity and drinking water but would displace a rural community and permanently alter a river ecosystem.

A

how a rights-based ethical system could be applied to this proposal.

[3]
Question 11
HL • Paper 1
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 1
Medium
Calculator Permitted

The coastal district of Lumea is considering whether to convert part of the Kiri mangrove forest into shrimp ponds. Two conservation organizations support protecting the mangroves, but they give different reasons.

A

which organization bases its argument primarily on intrinsic value.

[1]
B

Using Figure 2(a), the difference in the combined annual value of fishery income, avoided storm damage and tourism between one kilometre of intact mangrove and one kilometre of shrimp-pond coastline.

[3]
C

why Organization A and Organization B could support the same conservation policy while applying different ethical values.

[3]
D

whether the instrumental-value evidence alone provides a sufficient ethical basis for rejecting the shrimp-pond proposal.

[4]
Question 12
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

A survey investigated how beliefs about the relationship between humans and nature were associated with support for three management strategies for the fictional Orana Forest.

A

the respondent group showing the greatest support for engineered restoration after harvesting.

[1]
B

the difference in support for strict whole-habitat protection between respondents who believe humans have no superior status and those who believe nature exists primarily to meet human needs.

[1]
C

the relationship between beliefs about humans and nature and support for the three forest-management strategies.

[2]
D

how the three starting beliefs could lead to the contrasting management preferences shown.

[3]

Build a Practice Exam — ESS HL

Test your knowledge with a custom paper containing questions from selected topics.

Practice exam question preview
Practice exams dashboard preview
Question 13
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

The fictional Kelana Estuary is being considered for designation as a protected area. Figure 2(a) estimates selected annual benefits to people. Figure 2(b) presents statements made during a public consultation.

A

the total estimated annual instrumental value of the five benefits shown in Figure 2(a).

[1]
B

between the grounds for valuing the estuary used by speakers P and Q.

[2]
C

how speaker R demonstrates that instrumental and intrinsic value are not exclusive.

[2]
D

why excluding benefits without an estimated monetary value could affect, but would not necessarily eliminate, support for protection.

[2]
Question 14
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

Residents were asked which entities should receive direct moral consideration when decisions are made about a proposed mine beside the fictional River Luma. Respondents could select more than one entity.

A

the non-human entity most frequently assigned direct moral consideration.

[1]
B

the percentage-point difference between respondents assigning moral consideration to future human generations and to non-living nature.

[1]
C

how the scope of moral consideration changes across the entities shown.

[2]
D

what the data about the extent of moral responsibility accepted by the respondents.

[3]
Question 15
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

An introduced herbivore is damaging endemic plants on an island. Managers are considering killing the introduced animals to prevent further ecological damage.

A

how virtue ethics, consequentialist ethics and rights-based ethics could be applied to this decision.

[3]
Question 16
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Medium
Calculator Permitted

A city is selecting a site for a waste-processing facility. Information about the two communities nearest the proposed site is shown in the figure.

Indicators for the two communities nearest the proposed waste-processing site.

CommunityAnnual mean PM2.5PM_{2.5} / μg m−3\mu\text{g m}^{-3}Residents represented at planning meetings / %Median household incomeMajor industrial sites
East Haven349Lower2
West Ridge1361Higher0
A

why locating the facility in East Haven could raise concerns about environmental justice and equity.

[4]

Build a Practice Exam — ESS HL

Test your knowledge with a custom paper containing questions from selected topics.

Practice exam question preview
Practice exams dashboard preview
Question 17
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted

The government of the fictional country of Navora proposes a reservoir in the Aro Valley. The reservoir would supply water to a rapidly growing city but would flood a wetland and require households to relocate.

A

Using Figure 1(b), the stakeholder group with the greatest percentage opposition to the reservoir.

[1]
B

the ratio of the proposed engineered-wetland area to the natural wetland area that would be flooded.

[2]
C

how different beliefs about the relationship between humans and nature could account for the contrasting responses of water engineers and conservation scientists.

[4]
D

the ethical case for approving the reservoir.

[5]
Question 18
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted

The city of Daruna proposes a waste-to-energy incinerator. Three possible sites have been assessed. The city states that the facility would reduce landfill use and generate electricity.

Environmental and demographic indicators for wards associated with proposed incinerator sites.

Ward / siteMedian household income / currency unitsExisting fine particulate / μg m−3\mu\text{g m}^{-3}Proportion of minority ethnic groups / %
East Ward (Site A)18 0002768
Industrial fringe (Site B)31 0001934
Lake Ward (Site C)74 0001211

A

the site associated with the greatest existing environmental burden.

[1]
B

how many times greater consultation participation was in Lake Ward than in East Ward.

[2]
C

two reasons why locating the incinerator at Site A could be considered an environmental-justice issue.

[4]
D

equality from equity in the context of consultation for the proposed incinerator.

[2]
E

the ethical case for selecting Site B for the incinerator.

[5]
Question 19
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted

Introduced herbivores are damaging endemic vegetation and nesting habitat on the fictional island of Naro. Managers are considering three responses. Projected outcomes over five years are shown in Figure 4(a). Three advisers on the decision in Figure 4(b).

Projected five-year outcomes of three responses to introduced herbivores on Naro.

Projected outcome after five yearsImmediate removalFertility controlNo intervention
Herbivores deliberately killed900800
Herbivores expected to die from starvation20170450
Endemic nesting birds remaining12 0008 0003 000
Native vegetation cover / %785524
Programme cost / million LCU3.25.80.4

A

the ethical approach represented by each adviser X, Y and Z.

[3]
B

the total projected number of introduced herbivore deaths under fertility control.

[1]
C

why a consequentialist could support immediate removal rather than no intervention.

[2]
D

why the virtue-ethics statement may not a single management response.

[2]
Question 20
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted

A town compared two mosquito-control products during disease outbreaks. Product N is extracted from a naturally occurring plant. Product S is manufactured synthetically. Both were applied to equal areas.

Comparison of mosquito-control products applied to equal areas during disease outbreaks.

ProductLarvae eliminated / %Non-target mortality / %Disease cases per 10 000Public support / %
N (naturally derived)62144674
S (synthetic)8862139
A

one contrast between the measured outcomes and public support for the two products.

[2]
B

the percentage decrease in disease cases achieved by using product S rather than product N.

[1]
C

why choosing product N only because it is natural would be an appeal to nature fallacy.

[2]
D

two considerations that would provide a more reliable ethical basis for selecting a product.

[2]

Build a Practice Exam — ESS HL

Test your knowledge with a custom paper containing questions from selected topics.

Practice exam question preview
Practice exams dashboard preview
Question 21
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted

Four neighbourhoods in the fictional city of Varen surround a freight and industrial corridor. Figure 6(a) shows their locations. Figure 6(b) presents environmental and social indicators.

Environmental and social indicators for four neighbourhoods in Varen.

IndicatorABCD
Median household income / thousand currency units82617429
Annual mean fine-particle concentration / μg m−3\mu\text{g m}^{-3}11191331
Public green space / m2m^2 per resident2412204
Residents attending planning consultation / %1813215
Households lacking private transport / %8171046
A

the neighbourhood experiencing both the highest fine-particle concentration and the lowest participation in planning.

[1]
B

how many times greater the green-space provision per resident is in neighbourhood A than in neighbourhood D.

[1]
C

the evidence that neighbourhood D is experiencing environmental injustice.

[4]
D

between an equal and an equitable allocation of new air-filtration and green-space funding in this city.

[2]
Question 22
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted

A regional authority is comparing three strategies for meeting an estimated water shortfall. The fictional Avara Valley contains an old-growth woodland and culturally significant rock formations.

Figure 7(a). Comparison of water-shortfall strategies. Demand reduction includes leakage repair, efficiency standards and progressive water pricing.

Large valley reservoirDemand reductionRainwater tanks
Reliable water supplied or saved / million m3 year−1m^3\ \text{year}^{-1}905238
Old-growth habitat permanently lost / ha14004012
Residents permanently displaced620015
Construction and 10-year operation cost / million currency units760410500
Time to full operation / years734

A

the habitat loss per million cubic metres of reliable annual water for the large reservoir.

[1]
B

the stakeholder whose statement most clearly assigns intrinsic value to non-living nature.

[1]
C

how supporters using different ethical grounds could both favour demand reduction.

[2]
D

how conflicting beliefs about humans and nature could lead to different judgements about the reservoir.

[3]
Question 23
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted

The Orin River has been granted legal personhood by the parliament of a fictional country. Guardians may represent the river in court. A proposed copper-processing plant would create employment but increase water extraction and the risk of pollution.

Figure 3(b). Present situation and proposed copper-processing plant; proposed plant operation is 30 years and toxic-discharge probability is a model .

ScenarioDry-season river flow / m3 s−1\text{m}^3\ \text{s}^{-1}Total human water extraction / m3 s−1\text{m}^3\ \text{s}^{-1}Permanent jobsMajor toxic discharge probability over 30 years (model ) / %\%
Present situation2683100%0\%
Plant proposal261414607%7\%
A

the percentage of dry-season river flow that would be extracted under the plant proposal.

[2]
B

how granting the river legal personhood reflects the concept of moral standing.

[3]
C

how recognizing the moral standing of future generations could affect the decision about the plant.

[2]
D

whether legal personhood for the Orin River provides an adequate basis for deciding whether the plant should proceed.

[5]
Question 24
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted

Introduced goats are damaging vegetation on the fictional island of San Meru. The conservation authority is comparing three management strategies over a ten-year period.

A

the projected change in native shrub cover under aerial culling.

[2]
B

how a consequentialist could use the evidence to support aerial culling.

[3]
C

how a rights-based judgement of aerial culling may differ from the consequentialist judgement.

[3]
D

how virtue ethics, consequentialist ethics and rights-based ethics could be applied to select a goat-management strategy.

[5]

Build a Practice Exam — ESS HL

Test your knowledge with a custom paper containing questions from selected topics.

Practice exam question preview
Practice exams dashboard preview
Question 25
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted

The health ministry of Belora is considering releasing genetically modified male mosquitoes. Their offspring would rarely survive to adulthood. The targeted mosquito is native and transmits a serious disease.

Modeled outcomes over five years after a mosquito-release programme.

YearAdult mosquitoes, no release / indexAdult mosquitoes, release / indexDisease cases, no release / cases/yearDisease cases, release / cases/year
010010024 00024 000
11004824 50010 400
21001825 0005 200
31001125 5003 000
4100825 8002 100
5100626 0001 600

A

Using Figure 5(a), the percentage reduction in modeled annual disease cases at year 5 as a result of the release.

[2]
B

why Resident 1's statement illustrates the appeal to nature fallacy.

[3]
C

the ethical reasoning used by Resident 2 and Resident 3.

[2]
D

the ethical acceptability of releasing the genetically modified mosquitoes.

[5]
Question 26
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted

A government assessed three climate-policy pathways. Estimated costs and benefits are distributed differently between people alive during the first decade of the policy and people living later in the century.

Estimated outcomes of three climate-policy pathways.

PathwayFirst-decade cost / billion currency unitsAvoided damage, 2050–2100 / billion currency unitsSevere disruption by 2100 / %
Rapid transition42098018
Delayed transition21047043
No additional action40076
A

the net estimated monetary benefit of the rapid-transition pathway using the first-decade policy cost and avoided damage shown.

[1]
B

the percentage-point reduction in the probability of severe ecosystem disruption achieved by rapid transition compared with no additional action.

[1]
C

how a rights-based argument concerning future generations could support rapid transition.

[2]
D

the use of consequentialist ethics to choose between the three pathways.

[4]
Question 27
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted

A regional authority proposes reintroducing a native large predator to an upland ecosystem. The predator could regulate herbivore populations and support ecosystem recovery, but livestock farmers are concerned about animal losses and rural livelihoods.

A

how beliefs about the relationship between humans and nature may give rise to ecocentric, stewardship-oriented anthropocentric and technocentric perspectives.

[4]
B

how these three perspectives could influence decisions about the proposed predator reintroduction.

[7]
C

Using named examples, should the interests of an ecological community take priority over the livelihoods of people directly affected by conservation?

[9]
Question 28
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted

A government is considering prohibiting bottom trawling in a deep-sea region containing slow-growing corals and other organisms. The region supports commercial fisheries but remains poorly studied.

A

between instrumental value and intrinsic value, including why they are not mutually exclusive.

[4]
B

how instrumental value, intrinsic value and moral standing could be used to judge whether bottom trawling should be prohibited.

[7]
C

Using named examples, the claim that intrinsic value provides a stronger basis for biodiversity conservation than instrumental value.

[9]

Build a Practice Exam — ESS HL

Test your knowledge with a custom paper containing questions from selected topics.

Practice exam question preview
Practice exams dashboard preview
Question 29
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted

Following a large marine oil spill, scientists propose releasing genetically engineered bacteria that break down petroleum compounds. Opponents argue that releasing an artificial organism is necessarily wrong, while supporters argue that rapid removal of the oil is necessarily right.

A

why describing an entity or process as natural does not establish that it is morally good.

[4]
B

the ethical considerations, other than naturalness, that should be used to judge the proposed bacterial release.

[7]
C

Using named examples, should the natural or artificial origin of an intervention influence environmental policy?

[9]
Question 30
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted

A company proposes an open-pit lithium mine in the high-altitude Qala Basin. Lithium would be used in rechargeable batteries. The basin is also used by pastoral communities and supports salt-marsh habitats.

A

the percentage of mining jobs expected to go to basin residents.

[2]
B

one inequality shown by Figure 7(b).

[2]
C

how the proposed mine illustrates the overlap between environmental justice and social justice.

[4]
D

how an anthropocentric stewardship perspective and a technocentric perspective might lead to different conditions being placed on the mine.

[2]
E

could the lithium mine contribute to an equitable and sustainable future?

[4]
Question 31
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 1
Hard
Calculator Permitted

The government of Pelagos proposes a no-take marine reserve around the Aruna Archipelago. The reserve would protect a whale migration corridor and coral reefs, but would restrict fishing by nearby communities.

Pilot reserve and unprotected reference area over eight years.

YearPilot biomass / g m−2\text{g m}^{-2}Reference biomass / g m−2\text{g m}^{-2}Pilot whale sightingsReference whale sightingsCatch per fisher / tonnes
111511842393.6
212211745403.1
313011949402.8
414112054413.0
515011959413.3
616012064423.6
717312069433.9
818412173444.1

A

Using Figure 8(b), the percentage increase in reef-fish biomass in the pilot reserve over the eight years.

[2]
B

one instrumental value and one intrinsic value assigned to the marine ecosystem in the resources.

[2]
C

how the proposal raises questions about the moral standing of both non-human entities and future generations.

[3]
D

whether the proposed marine reserve represents an ethically justified approach to sustainability.

[6]
Question 32
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted

Climate change is making the historical habitat of a rare mountain plant unsuitable. Conservationists are considering assisted migration, in which the plant would be introduced to a cooler region outside its recorded natural range. The introduction could prevent extinction but might disrupt the recipient ecosystem.

A

the basis of moral judgement in virtue ethics, consequentialist ethics and rights-based ethics.

[4]
B

how each of these ethical approaches could be applied to the proposed assisted migration.

[7]
C

Using named examples, consequentialist ethics as a basis for managing species threatened by environmental change.

[9]

Build a Practice Exam — ESS HL

Test your knowledge with a custom paper containing questions from selected topics.

Practice exam question preview
Practice exams dashboard preview
Question 33
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted

A national energy company proposes constructing a large solar-energy development on semi-arid communal grazing land. The project would reduce fossil-fuel use and provide national electricity, but pastoral households could lose access to grazing areas and culturally significant places.

A

between social justice, environmental justice, equality and equity.

[4]
B

how environmental- and social-justice principles could be applied to the proposed solar-energy development.

[7]
C

Using named examples, can a transition to renewable energy be environmentally sustainable if it is not socially just?

[9]
Question 34
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted
HL • Paper 2
Hard
Calculator Permitted

Some governments are considering stratospheric aerosol injection as a possible response to climate change. This intervention would increase the reflection of incoming solar radiation and could lower global temperatures, but its regional and long-term consequences are uncertain.

A

how assigning moral standing to future generations broadens present human responsibility towards the environment.

[4]
B

how different ethical approaches could be used to judge the use of stratospheric aerosol injection.

[7]
C

Using named examples, the claim that precautionary restraint is ethically preferable to technological intervention when environmental consequences are uncertain.

[9]

HL.b Environmental economics