Clastify logo
Subjects
Features
Review
HOT Save 10%
Tutoring
Log in

B.4: Thermodynamics

Master IB Physics B.4: Thermodynamics with notes created by examiners and strictly aligned with the syllabus.

Verified by Kun
Verified by Kun

13 sections · ~24 min read

This content can't be printed from the browser. Use Export PDF with Pro for an offline copy.

IB Syllabus Requirements for Thermodynamics

B.4.1

First law of thermodynamics for a closed system

HL

B.4.2

Work done by or on a closed system when its boundaries change

HL

B.4.3

Internal energy change and temperature change in a monatomic ideal gas

HL

B.4.4

Entropy as a measure related to particle disorder

HL

B.4.1

FIRST LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS FOR A CLOSED SYSTEM

HL

Systems, surroundings and the bookkeeping of energy

A thermodynamic system is the part of the physical world we choose to study, focusing on its energy transfers and changes of state. The surroundings are everything outside that chosen system. Together, the system and surroundings form the thermodynamic “universe” for the problem. Choose the system first. A vague choice of system is where many sign errors in this topic start.

A closed system is a thermodynamic system that cannot exchange mass with its surroundings, although it can still exchange energy by heating or by doing work. The standard IB example is a fixed mass of gas under a piston: no gas particles enter or leave, but energy can cross the boundary.

The first law of thermodynamics states conservation of energy by linking the energy transferred into a closed system with the change in its internal energy and the work done by the system:

Q=ΔU+WQ = \Delta U + W

IB uses the Clausius sign convention. Positive QQ means energy is supplied to the system by heating. Positive ΔU\Delta U means the system’s internal energy store increases. Positive WW means the system does work. So work done on a system is negative, while work done by a system is positive. Keep that convention throughout a calculation; if you mix conventions, you can get physically nonsense answers even when the algebra looks neat.

Worked example: A fixed mass of gas receives 500 J500\ \text{J} by heating and expands, doing 200 J200\ \text{J} of work on its surroundings. Calculate the change in its internal energy.

  1. Assign signs: heating transfers energy into the gas, and the gas does work on its surroundings. Q=+500 J,W=+200 JQ = +500\ \text{J}, \qquad W = +200\ \text{J}
  2. Rearrange the first law and substitute: ΔU=Q−W=(+500 J)−(+200 J)=+300 J\Delta U = Q - W = (+500\ \text{J}) - (+200\ \text{J}) = +300\ \text{J}
Answer

Answer: ΔU=+300 J\Delta U = +300\ \text{J}. The gas’s internal energy increases by 300 J300\ \text{J} because the energy supplied by heating exceeds the energy transferred out by work.

Worked example: A gas is compressed with 120 J120\ \text{J} of work done on it, while 40 J40\ \text{J} is transferred out by heating. Calculate the change in its internal energy.

  1. Assign signs: work is done on the gas, and heating transfers energy out of it. W=−120 J,Q=−40 JW = -120\ \text{J}, \qquad Q = -40\ \text{J}
  2. Rearrange the first law and substitute: ΔU=Q−W=(−40 J)−(−120 J)=+80 J\Delta U = Q - W = (-40\ \text{J}) - (-120\ \text{J}) = +80\ \text{J}
Answer

Answer: ΔU=+80 J\Delta U = +80\ \text{J}. The gas’s internal energy increases by 80 J80\ \text{J} because the energy supplied by compression exceeds the energy lost by heating.

What the first law does and does not say

The first law says that work and heating are two ways to transfer energy across the system boundary. It does not say which processes can happen naturally. For example, conservation of energy alone would not rule out energy flowing spontaneously from a cold object to a hot object; the second law deals with that direction-of-change question later in this topic.

Joule’s paddle-wheel experiments mattered historically because they showed that mechanical work done on water can raise its temperature. In modern terms, doing work on a system can increase its internal energy, just as transferring energy by heating can.

B.4.2

WORK DONE BY OR ON A CLOSED SYSTEM WHEN ITS BOUNDARIES CHANGE

HL

Boundary work

When a gas pushes a movable piston, the system boundary shifts. The gas applies a force through a distance, so it does work. For a small change at constant pressure,

W=PΔVW = P\Delta V

  • If the gas expands, ΔV\Delta V is positive, so the gas does positive work on the surroundings.
  • If the gas is compressed, ΔV\Delta V is negative and the work done by the gas is negative; equivalently, work is being done on the gas.

The same result comes from looking at a piston of cross-sectional area AA, where AA is the piston area (m2m^2), moving a distance Δx\Delta x, where Δx\Delta x is the piston displacement (m). The force from the gas is PAPA and the volume change is ΔV=AΔx\Delta V = A\Delta x, so the work is force×distance=PAΔx=PΔV\text{force} \times \text{distance} = PA\Delta x = P\Delta V.

Worked example: A gas expands at a constant pressure of 200 kPa200\ \text{kPa} from 2.0 L2.0\ \text{L} to 5.0 L5.0\ \text{L}. Calculate the work done by the gas, then find the work done by the gas for the reverse compression at the same pressure.

  1. Convert the pressure to pascals:

    P=200×103 PaP = 200\times10^3\ \text{Pa}

  2. Calculate the volume change and convert litres to cubic metres:

    ΔV=5.0−2.0=3.0 L=3.0×10−3 m3\Delta V = 5.0-2.0 = 3.0\ \text{L} = 3.0\times10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3

  3. Substitute into the work equation:

    W=PΔV=(200×103)(3.0×10−3)=600 JW = P\Delta V = (200\times10^3)(3.0\times10^{-3}) = 600\ \text{J}

  4. For the reverse compression, the volume change has the opposite sign:

    ΔV=2.0−5.0=−3.0 L=−3.0×10−3 m3\Delta V = 2.0-5.0 = -3.0\ \text{L} = -3.0\times10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3

    W=(200×103)(−3.0×10−3)=−600 JW = (200\times10^3)(-3.0\times10^{-3}) = -600\ \text{J}

Answer

Answer: The gas does 600 J600\ \text{J} of work during expansion and −600 J-600\ \text{J} during the reverse compression. In the compression, 600 J600\ \text{J} of work is done on the gas.

PP–VV diagrams and area

A PP–VV diagram is a graph of pressure against volume used to represent a gas process. The work done by the gas equals the area under the process curve on a pressure–volume graph. That still holds when the pressure changes; in quantitative IB problems, you may have to estimate the area by counting squares or splitting the curve into thin vertical strips.

For a curved path, you can approximate the area by adding rectangular strip areas:

W≈∑PiΔViW \approx \sum P_i\Delta V_i

Thinner strips give a better estimate, but use practical judgement: in an exam, a sensible area estimate is usually what is being tested.

Worked example: Estimate the work done during an expansion from 2.0 L2.0\ \text{L} to 5.0 L5.0\ \text{L} along a curved path. Divide the volume range into three strips, each 1.0 L1.0\ \text{L} wide. Use representative pressures of 240 kPa240\ \text{kPa}, 200 kPa200\ \text{kPa} and 160 kPa160\ \text{kPa} for the successive strips.

  1. Convert each strip width to cubic metres:

    ΔVi=1.0 L=1.0×10−3 m3\Delta V_i = 1.0\ \text{L} = 1.0\times10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3

  2. Convert each pressure to pascals and calculate each rectangular area. Each strip extends from zero pressure up to its representative pressure.

StripPressure / Pa\text{Pa}Width / m3\text{m}^3Strip area / J\text{J}
1240×103240\times10^31.0×10−31.0\times10^{-3}(240×103)(1.0×10−3)=240(240\times10^3)(1.0\times10^{-3}) = 240
2200×103200\times10^31.0×10−31.0\times10^{-3}(200×103)(1.0×10−3)=200(200\times10^3)(1.0\times10^{-3}) = 200
3160×103160\times10^31.0×10−31.0\times10^{-3}(160×103)(1.0×10−3)=160(160\times10^3)(1.0\times10^{-3}) = 160
  1. Add the strip areas:

    W≈240+200+160=600 JW \approx 240+200+160 = 600\ \text{J}

Answer

Answer: The estimated work done by the gas is +600 J+600\ \text{J}. It is positive because the gas expands; it is an estimate because rectangles approximate the curved path.

Common mistake: Watch out for false origins. If a pressure–volume graph does not start from zero pressure and zero volume, the visible rectangle is not necessarily the whole area under the graph. Work uses the full area down to zero pressure, not just the neat-looking part inside the plotted grid. Include the additional area below a non-zero displayed pressure baseline, but only between the initial and final volumes; do not extend the area back to zero volume.

B.4.3

INTERNAL ENERGY CHANGE AND TEMPERATURE CHANGE IN A MONATOMIC IDEAL GAS

HL

Internal energy of a monatomic ideal gas

Internal energy is the total microscopic kinetic and potential energy associated with the particles of a system. In the ideal gas model, there is no intermolecular potential energy, so internal energy depends only on temperature. For a monatomic ideal gas,

ΔU=32NkBΔT=32nRΔT\Delta U = \frac{3}{2}N k_B \Delta T = \frac{3}{2}n R \Delta T

The equation is useful because it doesn’t depend on the path the gas takes between the initial temperature and the final temperature. Stir it, compress it, heat it slowly, heat it quickly: for a monatomic ideal gas, ΔT\Delta T alone fixes the change in internal energy.

Combining with the first law

The first law shows how that temperature change happened. If energy is supplied to a gas while the gas expands, part of the energy increases its internal energy and part is transferred as work done on the surroundings. If a gas is compressed adiabatically, Q=0Q = 0 and the negative value of WW makes ΔU\Delta U positive: work done on the gas raises its temperature.

Worked example: A sample of 0.200 mol0.200\ \text{mol} of helium warms from 300 K300\ \text{K} to 340 K340\ \text{K} and does 60.0 J60.0\ \text{J} of work on its surroundings. Calculate its internal-energy change and the energy supplied by heating. Treat helium as a monatomic ideal gas and use R=8.31 J mol−1 K−1R = 8.31\ \text{J mol}^{-1}\,\text{K}^{-1}.

  1. Calculate the temperature change:

    ΔT=340−300=40 K\Delta T = 340 - 300 = 40\ \text{K}

  2. Substitute into the internal-energy equation:

    ΔU=32nRΔT=32(0.200)(8.31)(40)=99.72 J≈99.7 J\Delta U = \frac{3}{2}nR\Delta T = \frac{3}{2}(0.200)(8.31)(40) = 99.72\ \text{J} \approx 99.7\ \text{J}

  3. Use the first law, taking work done by the gas as positive. Retain the unrounded internal-energy change for the calculation:

    ΔU=Q−W\Delta U = Q - W

    Q=ΔU+W=99.72+60.0=159.72 J≈160 JQ = \Delta U + W = 99.72 + 60.0 = 159.72\ \text{J} \approx 160\ \text{J}

Answer

Answer: The internal energy increases by 99.7 J99.7\ \text{J}, and the energy supplied by heating is 160 J160\ \text{J}. Heating supplies both the increase in internal energy and the 60.0 J60.0\ \text{J} transferred as work to the surroundings.

Quantitative problems in this topic are restricted to monatomic ideal gases, including situations where pressure is not constant. When pressure varies, don’t force W=PΔVW = P\Delta V with a single pressure value unless the process really is at constant pressure. Use the area under the PP–VV curve for work, and use the temperature change equation for ΔU\Delta U.

B.4.4

ENTROPY AS A MEASURE RELATED TO PARTICLE DISORDER

HL

Entropy and disorder

Entropy is a thermodynamic state quantity. It measures how many microscopic arrangements can produce the observed macroscopic state of a system. Its symbol is S, where S is entropy (J K−1\mathrm{J\,K^{-1}}).

The phrase “degree of disorder” can help, but only if used carefully. A gas spread through a whole container is more disordered than the same gas confined to one corner because the particles have far more possible positions. A crystal with a missing atom has more disorder than a perfect crystal because the vacancy could occupy many possible places.

Entropy is not a substance. It also isn’t “mess” in the everyday sense. It is a state property linked to probability: macroscopic states with many microscopic arrangements are overwhelmingly more likely than macroscopic states with very few microscopic arrangements. For that reason, thermodynamics can predict the future evolution of large systems statistically, even though individual particle motion is random.

B.4.5

ENTROPY FROM MACROSCOPIC QUANTITIES AND FROM MICROSTATES

HL

Macroscopic definition

For a reversible energy transfer at constant temperature, calculate the entropy change with

ΔS=ΔQ/T\Delta S = \Delta Q / T

Watch the sign.

  • When energy is transferred into the system, ΔQ\Delta Q is positive, so the system’s entropy increases.
  • When energy is transferred out of the system, ΔQ\Delta Q is negative, so the system’s entropy decreases.

Use this equation when the temperature is constant or changes negligibly; calculus versions are not required for IB Physics.

Worked example: A system absorbs 600 J600\ \text{J} reversibly at a constant temperature of 300 K300\ \text{K}. Calculate its entropy change.

  1. Energy enters the system, so ΔQ=+600 J\Delta Q = +600\ \text{J} and T=300 KT = 300\ \text{K}.
  2. Substitute into the macroscopic equation:
ΔS=ΔQT=+600300=+2.00 J K−1\Delta S = \frac{\Delta Q}{T} = \frac{+600}{300} = +2.00\ \text{J K}^{-1}
Answer

Answer: The system’s entropy increases by 2.00 J K−12.00\ \text{J K}^{-1}.

Microscopic definition

A microstate is one particular microscopic arrangement of the particles that produces the same observed macroscopic state. For example, if ten particles are divided between the left and right halves of a box, “five on the left” is a macrostate; the particular choice of which five particles are on the left is a microstate.

Entropy can also be written as

S=kBln⁡ΩS = k_B \ln \Omega

In the simple models used here, all microstates are assumed to be equally probable. That makes counting useful: a macrostate with more microstates is more likely to be observed.

A coin or counter model shows the idea neatly. If each counter can be in either of two boxes, the total number of arrangements doubles for every extra counter. The evenly split macrostate has many more microstates than the “all counters in one box” macrostate, so it is much more likely. For a mole of gas particles, the difference in probabilities is so extreme that the unlikely macroscopic states are never seen in practice.

Worked example: In a counting model, the number of accessible, equally probable microstates increases from Ωi=2\Omega_i = 2 to Ωf=8\Omega_f = 8. Calculate the entropy change using kB=1.380649×10−23 J K−1k_B = 1.380649 \times 10^{-23}\ \text{J K}^{-1}.

  1. Subtract the initial entropy from the final entropy:
ΔS=Sf−Si=kBln⁡Ωf−kBln⁡Ωi\Delta S = S_f - S_i = k_B\ln\Omega_f - k_B\ln\Omega_i
  1. Use the logarithm rule ln⁡a−ln⁡b=ln⁡(a/b)\ln a - \ln b = \ln(a/b):
ΔS=kBln⁡(ΩfΩi)\Delta S = k_B\ln\left(\frac{\Omega_f}{\Omega_i}\right)
  1. Substitute the microstate counts:
ΔS=(1.380649×10−23)ln⁡(82)=(1.380649×10−23)ln⁡4=1.91×10−23 J K−1\Delta S = (1.380649 \times 10^{-23})\ln\left(\frac{8}{2}\right) = (1.380649 \times 10^{-23})\ln 4 = 1.91 \times 10^{-23}\ \text{J K}^{-1}

The ratio appears because entropy depends on the logarithm of the count: subtracting two logarithms gives the logarithm of a ratio, not the logarithm of the difference 8−28 - 2.

Answer

Answer: The entropy increases by 1.91×10−23 J K−11.91 \times 10^{-23}\ \text{J K}^{-1} as the number of accessible microstates increases by a factor of 44.

Linking the two views

The macroscopic equation ΔS=ΔQ/T\Delta S = \Delta Q / T and the microscopic equation S=kBln⁡ΩS = k_B \ln \Omega describe the same physical idea in two ways. When a gas expands into a larger volume, Ω\Omega increases because the particles have more possible positions.

For a reversible isothermal expansion of an ideal gas, energy supplied to the gas is converted into work while the temperature remains fixed. The same entropy increase can therefore be described either by the reversible energy transfer or by the increased number of microstates.

Common mistake: Applying the actual heat transfer divided by temperature to an irreversible expansion. In the free expansion of a thermally insulated ideal gas into a vacuum, Q=W=0Q = W = 0 and the temperature remains constant, but entropy increases because more microstates become accessible. Entropy is a state function: calculate its change using an equivalent reversible isothermal path between the same initial and final states, so ΔS=Qrev/T\Delta S = Q_{\mathrm{rev}}/T, not the actual heat transfer of zero.

B.4.6

SECOND LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS AND CONSTRAINTS ON PHYSICAL PROCESSES

HL

Three equivalent ways to say the second law

An isolated system is a thermodynamic system that cannot exchange either mass or energy with its surroundings. With an isolated system, there’s no “outside” energy transfer available to make an impossible process happen.

The second law of thermodynamics restricts the direction of real thermodynamic processes. Energy conservation is not the whole story: the law also tells us which energy transfers can happen spontaneously.

StatementConstraintExample
Clausius formEnergy cannot be transferred spontaneously from a colder body to a hotter body. To do that, work has to be done on a device or system.A refrigerator needs electrical work to transfer energy from its cold interior to the warmer surroundings.
Kelvin formNo heat engine operating in a cycle can take energy from a single hot reservoir and turn all of it into work. Some energy must be rejected to a colder reservoir. This is why no cyclic heat engine is 100% efficient.A cyclic heat engine takes in energy from a hot reservoir, produces work and rejects some energy to a colder reservoir.
Entropy formThe entropy of an isolated system cannot decrease. For a reversible process in an isolated system, the entropy change is zero. For an irreversible process in an isolated system, entropy increases.When hot and cold bodies exchange energy spontaneously within an isolated system, energy transfers from the hotter body to the colder body and their total entropy increases.

Worked example: A proposed cyclic device absorbs 100 J100\ \text{J} from one reservoir and produces 100 J100\ \text{J} of work with no other effect. Assess whether it satisfies the first and second laws of thermodynamics.

  1. Check energy conservation. Over a complete cycle, the device returns to its initial state, so its internal energy change is zero. The energy balance gives: ΔU=Qin−Wout=100 J−100 J=0 J\Delta U = Q_{\text{in}} - W_{\text{out}} = 100\ \text{J} - 100\ \text{J} = 0\ \text{J} The proposed device satisfies the first law.
  2. Check the Kelvin statement. The device operates in a cycle and converts all the energy absorbed from a single reservoir into work, with no energy rejected to a colder reservoir. This violates the second law.
Answer

Answer: The device satisfies energy conservation because its net internal energy change is 0 J0\ \text{J} per cycle. It is nevertheless impossible because complete conversion of heat from a single reservoir into work, with no other effect, violates the Kelvin statement of the second law.

Consequences for the universe

If we treat the universe as the largest isolated system, the second law says that its total entropy tends to increase. Temperature differences act as the “fuel” for useful processes: engines, weather systems, stars radiating to space.

In the very long term, if all temperature differences were smoothed out and entropy reached a maximum, no heat engine-like process could extract useful work. This idea is often called the heat death hypothesis. It is a physical extrapolation from the second law, not an experiment we can actually run on the universe.

B.4.7

IRREVERSIBILITY AND ENTROPY INCREASE IN REAL ISOLATED SYSTEMS

HL

Why real processes do not simply run backwards

A reversible process is an idealised process that can be reversed by an infinitesimal change, with no net change left in the system and surroundings. To be reversible, a process must be quasi-static: slow enough to pass through a sequence of near-equilibrium states, so the system is effectively in thermodynamic equilibrium at every stage. This is necessary but not sufficient for reversibility. Reversible heat transfer also requires an infinitesimal temperature difference between the bodies exchanging energy.

Common mistake: Assuming that any sufficiently slow process is reversible. Slow compression with friction remains irreversible: friction dissipates energy, so reversing the piston’s motion does not restore both the system and surroundings to their initial states.

An irreversible process is a real process that cannot be undone without causing a net change somewhere else. Irreversible features include:

  • Friction and turbulence.
  • Unrestrained expansion and mixing.
  • Heat transfer across a finite temperature difference.

Most real isolated systems behave irreversibly, because energy spreads out among microscopic degrees of freedom. A piston moving with friction warms its surroundings; a gas expanding freely into a vacuum fills the available volume; two gases mix. Energy is still conserved in each case. The problem is that running the process backwards would need a fantastically unlikely microscopic rearrangement.

Example: An ideal gas initially occupies one side of an insulated rigid container, with a vacuum on the other side. Removing the partition lets the gas expand freely into the larger accessible volume. Insulation prevents heat transfer, so Q=0Q = 0; expansion against a vacuum does no work, so W=0W = 0. The first law therefore gives ΔU=0\Delta U = 0. For an ideal gas, internal energy depends only on temperature, so its temperature is unchanged even though ΔS>0\Delta S > 0. Restoring the gas to its initial volume and temperature requires external intervention, such as compression and heat transfer to the surroundings.

For an isolated system, irreversible change means entropy increases. “Almost always” matters here: the laws of mechanics do not forbid all particles from accidentally moving into a more ordered arrangement, but with macroscopic numbers of particles the probability is so tiny that it is physically irrelevant.

B.4.8

LOCAL ENTROPY DECREASE IN NON-ISOLATED SYSTEMS

HL

Local order is allowed

A non-isolated system is a thermodynamic system that can exchange energy, and possibly mass, with its surroundings. Its own entropy can decrease, as long as the surroundings gain at least the same amount of entropy.

Freezing water gives a neat example. The water becomes more ordered, so its entropy decreases. At the same time, it releases energy to colder surroundings, which gain more entropy than the water loses. For the water plus surroundings, the total entropy change is positive.

Living organisms are a useful check on the phrase “entropy always increases”. A plant builds ordered structures, but it isn’t an isolated system. Energy from the Sun, along with energy transfers to the environment, makes the total entropy change of the larger Sun–Earth–surroundings system positive. The second law forbids a total entropy decrease for an isolated system; it does not forbid local organisation.

B.4.9

ISOVOLUMETRIC, ISOBARIC, ISOTHERMAL AND ADIABATIC PROCESSES

HL

Four standard gas processes

A gas process is a change from one thermodynamic state of a gas to another. On a PP–VV diagram, each process has its own shape, which shows what happens to the work done. Here, WW is work done by the gas.

An isovolumetric process keeps volume constant. Since ΔV=0\Delta V = 0, no boundary work is done. The first law becomes Q=ΔUQ = \Delta U. For an ideal gas, PT=constant\frac{P}{T} = \text{constant} during a constant-volume process.

An isobaric process keeps pressure constant. Its PP–VV graph is horizontal, and the work done is W=PΔVW = P\Delta V. For an ideal gas,

VT=constant\frac{V}{T} = \text{constant}

An isothermal process keeps absolute temperature constant. For an ideal gas, internal energy does not change, so ΔU=0\Delta U = 0 and the first law gives Q=WQ = W. The ideal gas equation is PV=nRTPV = nRT, so for fixed nn and constant TT, PV=constantPV = \text{constant}. An isothermal expansion follows a downward-curving isotherm on a PP–VV graph.

An adiabatic process transfers no energy by heating across the system boundary, so Q=0Q = 0. Good insulation, or a process too rapid for significant thermal energy transfer, approximates this.

Slow, well-conducted changes give the best approximation to isothermal behaviour: the gas remains at the same temperature while energy crosses the boundary. Rapid, insulated changes approximate adiabatic behaviour because heating is negligible.

ProcessFixed quantityPP–VV shapeIdeal-gas relationFirst-law simplificationPractical setup
IsovolumetricVolumeVerticalP/T=constantP/T = \text{constant}Q=ΔUQ = \Delta URigid container
IsobaricPressureHorizontalV/T=constantV/T = \text{constant}Q=ΔU+PΔVQ = \Delta U + P\Delta VFreely moving, constant-load piston
IsothermalTemperatureHyperbolaPV=constantPV = \text{constant}ΔU=0\Delta U = 0; Q=WQ = WSlow piston, thermal reservoir
AdiabaticNo heat transferSteeper than isothermPVγ=constantPV^\gamma = \text{constant}, if reversibleQ=0Q = 0; ΔU=−W\Delta U = -WInsulated cylinder

For the adiabatic relation, γ=CP/CV\gamma = C_P/C_V is the ratio of heat capacities. No heat transfer does not mean no temperature change.

Worked example: Identify each process for a fixed amount of ideal gas and calculate the requested change.

  1. Rigid-container heating from 300 K300\ \text{K} to 450 K450\ \text{K}: volume is fixed, so P2=P1(T2/T1)=P1(450/300)=1.5P1P_2 = P_1(T_2/T_1) = P_1(450/300) = 1.5P_1.
  2. Constant-load piston heating over the same interval: pressure is fixed, so V2=V1(T2/T1)=V1(450/300)=1.5V1V_2 = V_1(T_2/T_1) = V_1(450/300) = 1.5V_1.
  3. Reversible isothermal expansion in contact with a thermal reservoir does 80 J80\ \text{J} of work: ΔU=0\Delta U = 0, so Q=ΔU+W=0+80=+80 JQ = \Delta U + W = 0 + 80 = +80\ \text{J}.
  4. Insulated compression has 80 J80\ \text{J} done on the gas: W=−80 JW = -80\ \text{J} and Q=0Q = 0, so ΔU=Q−W=0−(−80)=+80 J\Delta U = Q - W = 0 - (-80) = +80\ \text{J}.
Answer

Answer: Isovolumetric heating gives P2=1.5P1P_2 = 1.5P_1; isobaric heating gives V2=1.5V1V_2 = 1.5V_1. Isothermal expansion requires Q=+80 JQ = +80\ \text{J} with ΔU=0\Delta U = 0; adiabatic compression gives W=−80 JW = -80\ \text{J} and ΔU=+80 J\Delta U = +80\ \text{J}.

B.4.10

ADIABATIC PROCESSES IN MONATOMIC IDEAL GASES

HL

The adiabatic model

An adiabatic process transfers no heat: Q=0Q = 0. For a monatomic ideal gas undergoing a reversible, quasi-static adiabatic process,

PV5/3=constant\text{PV}^{5/3} = \text{constant}

The exponent 5/35/3 applies specifically to a monatomic ideal gas. In this topic, IB quantitative questions use monatomic ideal gases, so use this adiabatic model unless the question says otherwise, provided the process is reversible and quasi-static.

In reversible adiabatic expansion, the gas does positive work on the surroundings. Since Q=0Q = 0, the first law gives ΔU=−W\Delta U = -W, so the internal energy and temperature decrease. In adiabatic compression, WW is negative because work is done on the gas; ΔU\Delta U is positive, and the temperature rises.

On a P–V diagram, a reversible adiabatic curve is steeper than an isothermal curve passing through the same state. For expansion, pressure drops faster in a reversible adiabatic process because the gas cools as it expands. For compression, pressure rises faster because work done on the gas heats it.

Common mistake: Adiabatic does not automatically mean reversible. In insulated free expansion into a vacuum, no heat is transferred and no work is done, so an ideal gas's temperature stays constant. Do not apply the fractional-power pressure–volume relation to free expansion.

Worked example: A monatomic ideal gas expands reversibly and adiabatically from P1=100 kPaP_1 = 100\ \text{kPa}, V1=1.00×10−3 m3V_1 = 1.00 \times 10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3 and T1=300 KT_1 = 300\ \text{K} to V2=2V1V_2 = 2V_1. Find its final pressure, temperature and work done by the gas.

  1. Rearrange the adiabatic relation:
P2=P1(V1V2)5/3=(100 kPa)(12)5/3=31.5 kPaP_2 = P_1\left(\frac{V_1}{V_2}\right)^{5/3} = (100\ \text{kPa})\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^{5/3} = 31.5\ \text{kPa}
  1. For a fixed amount of ideal gas, temperature is proportional to pressure times volume:
T2=T1P2V2P1V1=(300 K)(31.5 kPa)(2.00×10−3 m3)(100 kPa)(1.00×10−3 m3)=189 KT_2 = T_1\frac{P_2V_2}{P_1V_1} = (300\ \text{K})\frac{(31.5\ \text{kPa})(2.00 \times 10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3)}{(100\ \text{kPa})(1.00 \times 10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3)} = 189\ \text{K}
  1. Use the monatomic internal energy and the first law, converting pressure to pascals:
W=−ΔU=32(P1V1−P2V2)=32[(100000 Pa)(1.00×10−3 m3)−(31500 Pa)(2.00×10−3 m3)]=55.5 JW = -\Delta U = \frac{3}{2}(P_1V_1-P_2V_2) = \frac{3}{2}\left[(100000\ \text{Pa})(1.00 \times 10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3)-(31500\ \text{Pa})(2.00 \times 10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3)\right] = 55.5\ \text{J}
Answer

Answer: The final pressure is 31.5 kPa31.5\ \text{kPa} and temperature is 189 K189\ \text{K}. The gas does 55.5 J55.5\ \text{J} of work on its surroundings.

B.4.11

CYCLIC GAS PROCESSES AND HEAT ENGINES

HL

Cycles and net work

A cyclic process is a sequence of thermodynamic changes that brings the system back to its initial state. Since internal energy is a state property, a gas that completes a full cycle has total ΔU=0\Delta U = 0 over the cycle.

On a P–V diagram, the net work done by the gas in one cycle equals the area enclosed by the loop. If the loop is clockwise, the gas does positive net work; if it is anticlockwise, net work is done on the gas.

A heat engine is a cyclic device that takes energy from a high-temperature reservoir, produces useful work, and rejects some energy to a lower-temperature reservoir. For a heat engine, QhQ_h is the energy transferred from the hot reservoir to the engine per cycle (J), QcQ_c is the energy rejected by the engine to the cold reservoir per cycle (J), ThT_h is the absolute temperature of the hot reservoir (K), and TcT_c is the absolute temperature of the cold reservoir (K).

After one complete cycle, the engine has returned to its starting internal energy. The useful work output is therefore the energy taken in minus the energy rejected:

Wnet=Qh−QcW_{\text{net}} = Q_h - Q_c

Steam engines, internal combustion engines and gas-turbine systems all use cyclic ideas, even though real engineering cycles are messier than neat textbook curves. The central idea stays the same: return the working substance to its initial state so the device can keep operating.

B.4.12

HEAT ENGINE EFFICIENCY

HL

Efficiency as useful output divided by input

Efficiency is a dimensionless ratio: useful energy output divided by total energy input. For a heat engine,

η=useful workinput energy\eta = \frac{\text{useful work}}{\text{input energy}}

For a cyclic heat engine, the expression is usually written as

η=WnetQh=Qh−QcQh\eta = \frac{W_{\text{net}}}{Q_h} = \frac{Q_h - Q_c}{Q_h}

Here, QhQ_h is the heat absorbed from the hot reservoir and QcQ_c is the magnitude of the heat rejected to the cold reservoir. The input energy is QhQ_h, not the net heat transfer.

Worked example: An engine absorbs Qh=2.50 kJQ_h = 2.50\ \text{kJ} and rejects Qc=1.75 kJQ_c = 1.75\ \text{kJ} per cycle. Calculate its net work output and efficiency.

  1. Calculate the net work output:

    Wnet=Qh−Qc=2.50−1.75=0.750 kJW_{\text{net}} = Q_h - Q_c = 2.50 - 1.75 = 0.750\ \text{kJ}

  2. Divide the useful work by the heat absorbed:

    η=WnetQh=0.7502.50=0.300=30.0%\eta = \frac{W_{\text{net}}}{Q_h} = \frac{0.750}{2.50} = 0.300 = 30.0\%

Answer

Answer: The net work output is 0.750 kJ0.750\ \text{kJ} per cycle and the efficiency is 30.0%30.0\%.

Engine cycles do not all have the same efficiency. They follow different paths on a P–V diagram, do different amounts of work, and reject different amounts of energy. Engineers often compare cycles using the area inside the P–V loop, but they also look at how much input energy is needed to produce that loop.

Example: Compare the engine above with an engine producing 1.00 kJ1.00\ \text{kJ} of net work from 5.00 kJ5.00\ \text{kJ} of heat input per cycle. The second engine has a larger P–V loop area because its net work is greater, but its efficiency is η=1.00/5.00=0.200=20.0%\eta = 1.00/5.00 = 0.200 = 20.0\%. It is less efficient because its heat input increases proportionally more than its work output.

Common mistake: Dividing work by QcQ_c or by Qh+QcQ_h + Q_c gives the wrong efficiency. Divide by QhQ_h: rejected heat is not an additional energy input.

Why efficiency matters beyond gas diagrams

Efficiency matters in motors and generators because any energy transfer that is not useful ends up as heating, sound, turbulence, frictional losses or some other wasted output. An electric motor is not usually treated as a heat engine, but its useful mechanical output still has to compete with unwanted heating. In a power station, a generator is often driven by a turbine. That turbine may sit inside a thermal cycle, so thermodynamic efficiency limits how much electrical energy can be obtained from the fuel or nuclear energy source.

Steam power shows how physics can change society. As people understood enough thermodynamics to improve engines, steam engines began driving factories, pumps, locomotives and ships. This was more than a better machine; it helped move many societies from local agricultural production toward industrial production, urbanisation and large-scale transport. The same physics also brought costs: pollution, fossil-fuel dependence and new social pressures.

B.4.13

CARNOT CYCLE AND MAXIMUM EFFICIENCY

HL

The reversible benchmark

A Carnot cycle is an ideal reversible heat-engine cycle made from two isothermal processes and two adiabatic processes. Engineers don’t copy it as a practical engine design. Instead, it acts as a benchmark: it gives the maximum possible efficiency for any engine working between two reservoir temperatures.

For a Carnot engine,

ηCarnot=1−TcTh\eta_\text{Carnot} = 1 - \frac{T_c}{T_h}

Use kelvin for the temperatures in this equation. A higher ThT_h or a lower TcT_c raises the theoretical maximum efficiency. That is why power-station engineers aim for high-temperature steam at the turbine inlet, then reject waste energy at as low a temperature as practical.

Worked example: An engine operates between reservoirs at 327 ∘C327\ ^\circ\text{C} and 27 ∘C27\ ^\circ\text{C}, absorbing Qh=1200 JQ_h = 1200\ \text{J} per cycle. Calculate its maximum efficiency and maximum work output per cycle. Is a claimed output of 720 J720\ \text{J} per cycle possible?

  1. Convert both reservoir temperatures to kelvin, using the Celsius-to-kelvin offset rounded to 273 K273\ \text{K}:

    Th=(327+273) K=600 KT_h = (327 + 273)\ \text{K} = 600\ \text{K}

    Tc=(27+273) K=300 KT_c = (27 + 273)\ \text{K} = 300\ \text{K}

  2. Substitute the absolute temperatures into the Carnot equation:

    ηmax⁡=1−TcTh=1−300600=0.500=50.0%\eta_{\max} = 1 - \frac{T_c}{T_h} = 1 - \frac{300}{600} = 0.500 = 50.0\%

  3. Use efficiency to find the maximum work output:

    Wmax⁡=ηmax⁡Qh=0.500×1200 J=600 JW_{\max} = \eta_{\max} Q_h = 0.500 \times 1200\ \text{J} = 600\ \text{J}

  4. Test the claimed output against the limit:

    ηclaimed=WQh=7201200=0.600=60.0%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = \frac{W}{Q_h} = \frac{720}{1200} = 0.600 = 60.0\%

    An energy balance alone could be written by assigning the remaining energy to the cold reservoir:

    Qc=Qh−W=1200 J−720 J=480 JQ_c = Q_h - W = 1200\ \text{J} - 720\ \text{J} = 480\ \text{J}

    This conserves energy, but the claimed efficiency exceeds the Carnot limit and therefore violates the second law.

Answer

Answer: The maximum efficiency is 50.0%50.0\%, giving a maximum work output of 600 J600\ \text{J} per cycle. The claimed 720 J720\ \text{J} per cycle is impossible between these reservoirs, even though an energy balance can be written.

Why there is an upper limit

The Kelvin form of the second law says that a cyclic engine cannot convert all input energy into work. Put in reservoir terms, QcQ_c cannot be zero for a real engine operating between finite temperatures. The Carnot equation says the same thing another way: ηCarnot\eta_\text{Carnot} would reach 11 only if TcT_c were 0 K0\ \text{K}, which cannot be achieved physically as an operating cold reservoir.

Real engines fall below the Carnot limit because their processes involve friction, turbulence, finite-rate heat transfer and other irreversible effects. There is a practical trade-off as well. The reversible isothermal stages of a Carnot cycle would need to be carried out infinitely slowly, so the cycle gives an ideal efficiency limit, not a useful high-power machine.

Were those notes helpful?

B.3 Gas laws

B.5 Current and circuits