Clastify logo
Subjects
Features
Review
HOT Save 10%
Tutoring
Log in

A.5: Galilean and special relativity

Master IB Physics A.5: Galilean and special relativity with notes created by examiners and strictly aligned with the syllabus.

Verified by Kun
Verified by Kun

9 sections · ~20 min read

This content can't be printed from the browser. Use Export PDF with Pro for an offline copy.

IB Syllabus Requirements for Galilean and special relativity

A.5.1

Reference frames and events

HL

A.5.2

Galilean relativity and Galilean transformations

HL

A.5.3

Einstein’s postulates and Lorentz transformations

HL

A.5.4

Relativistic velocity addition

HL

A.5.1

REFERENCE FRAMES AND EVENTS

HL

Frames, coordinates and events

A reference frame is a coordinate system with an origin, axes and clocks, used to measure the positions and times of events. In this topic, we usually take one space coordinate, along the direction of relative motion, and one time coordinate. Real spacetime has three space coordinates and one time coordinate, but the IB treatment keeps the algebra one-dimensional.

An event is one occurrence, fixed by where and when it happens in a chosen reference frame. A spark at the nose of a rocket, a detector click, or two clocks meeting are events. Relativity is not mainly about objects looking strange. It deals with different inertial frames giving different coordinates to the same events.

Example: A detector click is recorded in a laboratory frame as (x,t)=(12 m,4.0 s)(x, t) = (12\ \text{m}, 4.0\ \text{s}). The local ruler locates the detector at x=12 mx = 12\ \text{m} relative to the laboratory origin. A synchronized laboratory clock beside the detector reads t=4.0 st = 4.0\ \text{s} when it clicks. A frame moving relative to the laboratory assigns different coordinates to this same click; the event itself does not change.

An observer is a reference frame fitted with synchronized clocks and rulers throughout the frame, not just a person looking through a telescope. That distinction matters: when we say an observer measures an event, picture a local clock and a local ruler at the place where the event occurs.

Inertial frames

An inertial reference frame is a reference frame that is not accelerating. In such a frame, a free object stays at rest or moves with constant velocity. Two inertial frames may move relative to one another, but only with constant velocity.

A rotating frame, or a frame fixed in an accelerating car, is not inertial; you would need to introduce extra fictitious forces to make Newton’s laws work there.

Worked example: State and explain whether a frame fixed to a train moving at constant velocity on a straight track, and a frame fixed to a car turning at constant speed, are inertial. Treat the ground as an inertial frame.

  1. For the train, neither the magnitude nor the direction of velocity changes, so its acceleration is zero.
  2. For the turning car, the direction of velocity changes even though its speed is constant, so it has centripetal acceleration.
Answer

Answer: The train’s frame is inertial because it has zero acceleration relative to the ground. The turning car’s frame is non-inertial because its changing velocity direction means it is accelerating.

Common mistake: Constant speed alone does not make a frame inertial. Constant velocity requires both constant speed and constant direction; a turning car accelerates even if its speedometer reading stays unchanged.

For this topic, every transformation is between inertial frames moving at constant relative velocity along one shared axis. The restriction is intentional: once acceleration enters, the simple special-relativity formulae need more careful handling.

A.5.2

GALILEAN RELATIVITY AND GALILEAN TRANSFORMATIONS

HL

The Galilean idea

Galilean relativity says that Newton’s laws of motion keep the same form in every inertial reference frame. If you’re inside a sealed cabin moving smoothly, no experiment based on Newtonian mechanics can tell you whether the cabin is “really at rest” or moving at constant velocity. Rest depends on the frame.

For two frames whose origins coincide at zero time, with frame S′S' moving at constant velocity along the positive x-axis of frame SS, the Galilean transformation is

x′=x−vtandt′=tx' = x - vt \quad \text{and} \quad t' = t

Built into this is the quiet assumption of absolute time: all inertial observers agree on time intervals.

The matching velocity addition equation is

u′=u−vu' = u - v

Watch the sign of vv. If S′S' moves in the negative x-direction, then vv is negative and the same formula still works.

Worked example: A train frame S′S' moves at v=+20 m s−1v = +20\ \text{m s}^{-1} relative to the platform frame SS. Their origins coincide at zero time. An event has coordinates x=150 mx = 150\ \text{m} and t=5.0 st = 5.0\ \text{s} in SS. Find its coordinates in S′S'. Also find the velocity in S′S' of an object moving at u=+23 m s−1u = +23\ \text{m s}^{-1} in SS.

  1. Transform the position. The term vtvt is the train origin’s displacement from the platform origin:

    x′=x−vt=150 m−(20 m s−1)(5.0 s)=50 mx' = x - vt = 150\ \text{m} - (20\ \text{m s}^{-1})(5.0\ \text{s}) = 50\ \text{m}

  2. Transform the time. Galilean transformations assume absolute time:

    t′=t=5.0 st' = t = 5.0\ \text{s}

  3. Transform the object’s velocity using the same frame velocity:

    u′=u−v=(+23 m s−1)−(+20 m s−1)=+3.0 m s−1u' = u - v = (+23\ \text{m s}^{-1}) - (+20\ \text{m s}^{-1}) = +3.0\ \text{m s}^{-1}

Answer

Answer: The event occurs at x′=50 mx' = 50\ \text{m} and t′=5.0 st' = 5.0\ \text{s} in the train frame. The object moves at u′=+3.0 m s−1u' = +3.0\ \text{m s}^{-1}, in the positive x-direction relative to the train.

Example: If instead the train moves at v=−20 m s−1v = -20\ \text{m s}^{-1}, keeping the same event coordinates and object velocity in SS, then x′=150 m−(−20 m s−1)(5.0 s)=250 mx' = 150\ \text{m} - (-20\ \text{m s}^{-1})(5.0\ \text{s}) = 250\ \text{m} and u′=(+23 m s−1)−(−20 m s−1)=+43 m s−1u' = (+23\ \text{m s}^{-1}) - (-20\ \text{m s}^{-1}) = +43\ \text{m s}^{-1}. The time remains t′=5.0 st' = 5.0\ \text{s}.

Common mistake: Confusing vv with uu. The quantity vv describes the moving frame S′S' relative to SS, not the object; uu describes the object relative to SS. Assign signs using the chosen positive direction before substituting.

Why Galilean transformations cannot be the whole story

Galilean velocity addition works neatly for buses, walkways and laboratory carts. Light is the problem. If ordinary velocity addition applied to a light beam, different inertial observers would measure different speeds for that same light. Electromagnetism does not allow this: light in vacuum has one universal speed. That crack in the Newtonian picture is what special relativity repairs.

A.5.3

EINSTEIN’S POSTULATES AND LORENTZ TRANSFORMATIONS

HL

The two postulates

A postulate is an assumption taken as the starting point for a theory. Einstein’s special relativity starts with two postulates:

  • The laws of physics are the same in all inertial reference frames.
  • The speed of light in vacuum, cc, is the same for all inertial observers, where cc is the speed of light in vacuum (m s−1^{-1}).

Exam tip: For “State the two postulates”, write: “The laws of physics are the same in all inertial reference frames. The speed of light in vacuum is the same for all inertial observers, independent of the motion of its source and observer.”

Common mistake: Omitting “inertial frames” or “in vacuum” makes the postulates imprecise. Include both qualifications, and make clear that the measured speed of light is independent of the motion of both its source and observer.

The second postulate is the one that clashes most with everyday mechanics. Sound needs a medium, so the motion of the source and observer relative to the air affects what they measure. Light does not need a material medium in vacuum, and its speed is not found by adding the speed of the source to the speed of the wave. That is why the Doppler equation for light has a relativistic form, while the school-level Doppler equation for sound depends on motion relative to the medium.

Lorentz factor

The shift from Galilean to relativistic transformations is controlled by the Lorentz factor, a dimensionless factor that measures how strongly relativistic effects show up:

γ=11−v2c2\gamma = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1-\frac{\text{v}^{2}}{\text{c}^{2}}}}

At ordinary speeds v≪cv \ll c, γ\gamma is very close to 1, so Galilean mechanics works as an excellent approximation. As vv approaches cc, γ\gamma rises very rapidly; mathematically, this is one sign that massive objects cannot be accelerated to the speed of light.

Lorentz transformations

The Lorentz transformation relates measurements of the same event in two inertial frames moving at constant relative velocity. For motion along the x-axis,

x′=γ(x−vt)x' = \gamma(x-vt)

t′=γ(t−vxc2)t' = \gamma\left(t-\frac{vx}{\text{c}^{2}}\right)

These equations are given in the IB syllabus; their derivation is not required. The key idea is hard to miss: space and time get mixed together. The transformed position depends on time, and the transformed time depends on position. Here, “space” and “time” stop acting like separate absolute backgrounds and become spacetime.

Worked example: Frame S′S' moves at v=+0.60cv = +0.60c along the positive x-axis relative to frame SS. Their origins coincide at t=t′=0t = t' = 0. An event has coordinates x=900 mx = 900\ \text{m} and t=5.0 μst = 5.0\ \mu\text{s} in SS. Calculate γ\gamma and the event coordinates x′x' and t′t', using c=3.00×108 m s−1c = 3.00 \times 10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}.

  1. Convert the data to SI units:

    v=+0.60(3.00×108)=+1.80×108 m s−1v = +0.60(3.00 \times 10^8) = +1.80 \times 10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}

    t=5.0 μs=5.0×10−6 st = 5.0\ \mu\text{s} = 5.0 \times 10^{-6}\ \text{s}

  2. Calculate the Lorentz factor:

    γ=11−(0.60)2=10.64=1.25\gamma = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1-(0.60)^2}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{0.64}} = 1.25

  3. Transform the position, using SI values inside the brackets:

    x′=1.25[900−(1.80×108)(5.0×10−6)] mx' = 1.25\left[900-(1.80 \times 10^8)(5.0 \times 10^{-6})\right]\ \text{m}

    x′=1.25[900−900] m=0 mx' = 1.25[900-900]\ \text{m} = 0\ \text{m}

  4. Calculate the time correction before subtracting it. Its unit is time, not distance:

    vxc2=(1.80×108)(900)(3.00×108)2 s=1.80×10−6 s\frac{vx}{c^2} = \frac{(1.80 \times 10^8)(900)}{(3.00 \times 10^8)^2}\ \text{s} = 1.80 \times 10^{-6}\ \text{s}

    t′=1.25[5.0×10−6−(1.80×108)(900)(3.00×108)2] st' = 1.25\left[5.0 \times 10^{-6}-\frac{(1.80 \times 10^8)(900)}{(3.00 \times 10^8)^2}\right]\ \text{s}

    t′=1.25[5.0×10−6−1.80×10−6] s=4.0×10−6 st' = 1.25[5.0 \times 10^{-6}-1.80 \times 10^{-6}]\ \text{s} = 4.0 \times 10^{-6}\ \text{s}

Answer

Answer: γ=1.25\gamma = 1.25, x′=0 mx' = 0\ \text{m} and t′=4.0 μst' = 4.0\ \mu\text{s}. The frames assign different times to the same event because time coordinates depend on both position and time in the other frame through the Lorentz transformation; there is no universal time shared by the frames.

When v≪cv \ll c, γ≈1\gamma \approx 1 and vx/c2vx/c^2 is negligible for ordinary scales, so the Lorentz transformations reduce to the Galilean transformations. In relativistic contexts, equations of linear motion are adapted by replacing transformations between frames with Lorentz transformations whenever speeds are a significant fraction of cc, not by throwing away earlier mechanics.

Special relativity also sets a fundamental limit: no information or material object travels faster than light in vacuum. Physics has other limits as well, such as measurement uncertainty in quantum mechanics and practical limits set by detector resolution, but the speed limit cc is built into the structure of spacetime itself.

A.5.4

RELATIVISTIC VELOCITY ADDITION

HL

Why velocity addition changes

With Galilean velocity addition, an observer moving towards a light beam could measure that beam as travelling faster than cc. That clashes with Einstein’s second postulate. Using the Lorentz transformations gives the relativistic velocity addition equation instead:

u′=u−v1−uvc2u' = \frac{u-v}{1-\frac{uv}{\text{c}^{2}}}

Choose a positive direction along the common axis of two inertial frames:

  • uu is the object’s velocity measured in frame SS.
  • vv is the velocity of frame S′S' measured in frame SS.
  • u′u' is the same object’s velocity measured in frame S′S'.

There are two quick checks:

  • If u=cu=c, then u′=cu'=c, so every inertial observer still measures light in vacuum at speed cc.
  • If uu and vv are both much smaller than cc, then uv/c2uv/c^2 is tiny, and the equation reduces to u′≈u−vu' \approx u-v, which is the Galilean result.

For signs, ask first what the Galilean answer would suggest. When the object and the moving frame both travel in the same positive direction, uu and vv are positive in the subtraction form above. When one velocity points the other way, make that velocity negative; the denominator then adjusts on its own. No extra rule is being added here — it’s just signed velocity used consistently.

Worked cases: assigning frames and signs

Worked example: An object moves at u=+0.80cu=+0.80c relative to frame SS. An observer’s frame S′S' moves at v=+0.60cv=+0.60c relative to SS, in the same direction as the object. Find the object’s velocity u′u' measured by this observer, using c=3.00×108 m s−1c=3.00\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}.

  1. Assign the signed velocities: u=+0.80cu=+0.80c measures the object’s motion in SS; v=+0.60cv=+0.60c measures the observer’s motion in SS. The Galilean prediction is u−v=+0.20c=+6.00×107 m s−1u-v=+0.20c=+6.00\times10^7\ \text{m s}^{-1}.
  2. Substitute into both numerator and denominator:

u′=(+0.80c)−(+0.60c)1−(+0.80c)(+0.60c)c2=0.201−0.48c=0.200.52cu'=\frac{(+0.80c)-(+0.60c)}{1-\frac{(+0.80c)(+0.60c)}{c^2}}=\frac{0.20}{1-0.48}c=\frac{0.20}{0.52}c

  1. Convert to SI units:

u′≈+0.385c≈+1.15×108 m s−1u'\approx+0.385c\approx+1.15\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}

Answer

Answer: The observer measures u′=+1.15×108 m s−1u'=+1.15\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}, still in the positive direction. This is greater than the Galilean prediction of +0.20c+0.20c.

Worked example: The object still moves at u=+0.80cu=+0.80c in frame SS, but the observer’s frame now moves at v=−0.60cv=-0.60c relative to SS, opposite to the object’s motion. Find the object’s velocity u′u' measured in S′S'.

  1. Assign the signed velocities: u=+0.80cu=+0.80c and v=−0.60cv=-0.60c. The Galilean prediction is u−v=0.80c−(−0.60c)=+1.40c=+4.20×108 m s−1u-v=0.80c-(-0.60c)=+1.40c=+4.20\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}, which exceeds cc.
  2. Substitute the negative value of vv into both numerator and denominator:

u′=(+0.80c)−(−0.60c)1−(+0.80c)(−0.60c)c2=1.401+0.48c=1.401.48cu'=\frac{(+0.80c)-(-0.60c)}{1-\frac{(+0.80c)(-0.60c)}{c^2}}=\frac{1.40}{1+0.48}c=\frac{1.40}{1.48}c

  1. Convert to SI units:

u′≈+0.946c≈+2.84×108 m s−1u'\approx+0.946c\approx+2.84\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}

Answer

Answer: The observer measures u′=+2.84×108 m s−1u'=+2.84\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}, below cc, rather than the Galilean prediction of +1.40c+1.40c.

Exam tip: Define the frames and positive direction, then assign signed values to uu and vv before substituting. Do not select a different formula from the direction of motion alone: the stated transformation handles both cases when the signs are used consistently.

A.5.5

INVARIANT SPACETIME INTERVAL, PROPER TIME AND PROPER LENGTH

HL

Invariant quantities

An invariant quantity is a physical quantity with the same value in all inertial reference frames. In Galilean relativity, time intervals are invariant. In special relativity, time and distance do not stay invariant separately; the invariant quantity combines both.

The spacetime interval is an invariant separation between two events, defined for one space dimension by

(Δs)2=(cΔt)2−(Δx)2(\Delta s)^2 = (c\Delta t)^2 - (\Delta x)^2

For three space dimensions, the interval becomes (Δs)2=(cΔt)2−(Δx)2−(Δy)2−(Δz)2(\Delta s)^2=(c\Delta t)^2-(\Delta x)^2-(\Delta y)^2-(\Delta z)^2, although IB questions in this topic normally keep the motion along one axis.

The sign of (Δs)2(\Delta s)^2 tells us what kind of cause-and-effect link is possible:

  • A time-like interval is a spacetime separation for which (Δs)2>0(\Delta s)^2>0, so the events can occur at the same place in some inertial frame and one event could influence the other at a speed below cc.
  • A space-like interval is a spacetime separation for which (Δs)2<0(\Delta s)^2<0, so the events can occur at the same time in some inertial frame but cannot be causally connected without faster-than-light influence.
  • A light-like interval is a spacetime separation for which (Δs)2=0(\Delta s)^2=0, so the events can be connected by light travelling in vacuum.

Worked example: Two events have Δt=5.0 μs\Delta t=5.0\ \mu\text{s} and Δx=900 m\Delta x=900\ \text{m}. Calculate their interval and check invariance in a frame moving at +0.60c+0.60c, where Δx′=0\Delta x'=0 and Δt′=4.0 μs\Delta t'=4.0\ \mu\text{s}. Use c=3.0×108 m s−1c=3.0\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}.

  1. Calculate the light-travel distance:

    cΔt=(3.0×108 m s−1)(5.0×10−6 s)=1500 mc\Delta t=(3.0\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1})(5.0\times10^{-6}\ \text{s})=1500\ \text{m}

  2. Calculate the interval in the original frame:

    (Δs)2=(1500 m)2−(900 m)2=1.44×106 m2(\Delta s)^2=(1500\ \text{m})^2-(900\ \text{m})^2=1.44\times10^6\ \text{m}^2

  3. Check the moving frame:

    cΔt′=(3.0×108 m s−1)(4.0×10−6 s)=1200 mc\Delta t'=(3.0\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1})(4.0\times10^{-6}\ \text{s})=1200\ \text{m}

    (Δs′)2=(1200 m)2−(0 m)2=1.44×106 m2(\Delta s')^2=(1200\ \text{m})^2-(0\ \text{m})^2=1.44\times10^6\ \text{m}^2

Answer

Answer: Both frames give (Δs)2=1.44×106 m2(\Delta s)^2=1.44\times10^6\ \text{m}^2. It is positive, so the separation is time-like.

Example: Keeping Δt=5.0 μs\Delta t=5.0\ \mu\text{s}, a separation of 1800 m1800\ \text{m} gives (Δs)2=(1500 m)2−(1800 m)2=−9.9×105 m2(\Delta s)^2=(1500\ \text{m})^2-(1800\ \text{m})^2=-9.9\times10^5\ \text{m}^2: space-like. A separation of 1500 m1500\ \text{m} gives (Δs)2=0 m2(\Delta s)^2=0\ \text{m}^2: light-like.

Proper time and proper length

A proper time interval is the time interval between two events measured in the inertial frame where the two events occur at the same position. It is the time shown by a clock that is present at both events.

For a time-like separation, in the frame where Δx=0\Delta x=0,

(Δs)2=c2(Δt0)2(\Delta s)^2=c^2(\Delta t_0)^2

The moving frame in the worked example therefore measures Δt0=4.0 μs\Delta t_0=4.0\ \mu\text{s}.

A proper length is the length of an object measured in the inertial frame where the object is at rest. To measure a length in any frame, the positions of both ends must be measured simultaneously in that same frame. That last phrase is the bit students often skip; don’t. It is essential.

Example: A spacecraft’s stationary crew measure its nose-to-tail length as 100 m100\ \text{m}, so L0=100 mL_0=100\ \text{m}. A platform observer must record both end positions simultaneously in the platform frame.

Key point: “Proper” is selected by the measurement conditions, not by which observer is called stationary.

A.5.6

TIME DILATION AND LENGTH CONTRACTION

HL

Time dilation

Time dilation is the effect where a time interval measured in a frame in which the two events happen at different positions is longer than the proper time interval. The equation is

Δt=γΔt0\Delta t = \gamma\Delta t_0

The IB syllabus doesn’t require the derivation, but the physical meaning matters: moving clocks are measured to run slow. More time passes in the observing frame between ticks of the moving clock.

A light-clock picture helps. In the clock’s own frame, the light travels straight up and down. In a frame where the clock is moving, the light takes a longer diagonal path. Since both observers measure the same light speed cc, that longer path goes with a longer time interval.

Time dilation is symmetrical between inertial frames: each inertial observer measures the other observer’s clock as running slow. There’s no contradiction here, because each observer uses a different set of synchronized clocks spread through their own frame.

Length contraction

Length contraction is the effect where the length of an object measured in a frame in which the object is moving is shorter than its proper length. The equation is

L=L0γL = \frac{L_0}{\gamma}

The contraction happens only along the direction of relative motion. In this one-dimensional treatment, there is no contraction perpendicular to the relative motion.

Worked example: A spacecraft moves at v=0.80cv = 0.80c relative to an inertial platform. Two ticks of one onboard clock are separated by Δt0=3.0 μs\Delta t_0 = 3.0\ \mu\text{s} in the spacecraft frame. The spacecraft’s proper length along its direction of motion is L0=120 mL_0 = 120\ \text{m}. Calculate the interval between these ticks and the spacecraft’s length, both measured in the platform frame.

  1. Identify the frames before substituting. The ticks occur at the same position in the spacecraft frame, so the onboard clock measures the proper interval Δt0\Delta t_0. The spacecraft is also at rest in this frame, so its onboard length measurement is L0L_0. In the platform frame, the spacecraft moves at v=0.80cv = 0.80c; the required measurements are Δt\Delta t and LL.

  2. Calculate the Lorentz factor for this relative speed:

    γ=11−v2/c2=11−(0.80c)2/c2=10.36≈1.667\gamma = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1-v^2/c^2}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1-(0.80c)^2/c^2}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{0.36}} \approx 1.667

    The Lorentz factor is dimensionless.

  3. Calculate the platform interval between the two onboard ticks:

    Δt=γΔt0=1.667×3.0 μs=5.0 μs\Delta t = \gamma\Delta t_0 = 1.667 \times 3.0\ \mu\text{s} = 5.0\ \mu\text{s}

    Check: Δt>Δt0\Delta t > \Delta t_0, since 5.0 μs>3.0 μs5.0\ \mu\text{s} > 3.0\ \mu\text{s}. The platform measures a longer interval between ticks of the moving clock.

  4. Calculate the platform length, using endpoint positions measured simultaneously in the platform frame:

    L=L0γ=120 m1.667=72 mL = \frac{L_0}{\gamma} = \frac{120\ \text{m}}{1.667} = 72\ \text{m}

    Check: L<L0L < L_0, since 72 m<120 m72\ \text{m} < 120\ \text{m}. The platform measures a shorter length along the direction of motion.

Answer

Answer: In the platform frame, the interval between the onboard clock’s ticks is Δt=5.0 μs\Delta t = 5.0\ \mu\text{s} and the spacecraft’s length is L=72 mL = 72\ \text{m}. The corresponding spacecraft-frame measurements are Δt0=3.0 μs\Delta t_0 = 3.0\ \mu\text{s} and L0=120 mL_0 = 120\ \text{m}.

These equations replace the old assumption that time intervals and lengths stay the same in every inertial frame. At everyday speeds γ≈1\gamma\approx 1, so the Newtonian equations of linear motion are still a very good approximation. At relativistic speeds, you need to be precise about which frame supplies each time, distance and speed.

A.5.7

RELATIVITY OF SIMULTANEITY

HL

Simultaneity is not absolute

Simultaneity means that two events have the same time coordinate in a chosen reference frame. In Galilean relativity, simultaneity is absolute because t′=tt'=t. In special relativity, it depends on the inertial frame.

The Lorentz time transformation shows why. For two events,

Δt′=γ(Δt−vΔxc2)\Delta t' = \gamma\left(\Delta t - \frac{v\Delta x}{\text{c}^{2}}\right)

Suppose two events are simultaneous in S, so Δt=0\Delta t=0. If they happen at different positions, with Δx≠0\Delta x\neq 0, then Δt′≠0\Delta t'\neq 0 for frames in relative motion. Only events at the same position can be simultaneous in both frames.

Worked example: Two flashes, A and B, are simultaneous in S. Flash B occurs 600 m600\ \text{m} farther along the positive xx direction than flash A. Frame S′ moves at +0.60c+0.60c relative to S. Calculate Δt′=tB′−tA′\Delta t' = t'_B - t'_A and state which flash occurs first in S′. Use c=3.00×108 m s−1c = 3.00 \times 10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}.

  1. Define the differences in the same order, B minus A:
Δt=tB−tA=0 s,Δx=xB−xA=+600 m\Delta t = t_B-t_A = 0\ \text{s}, \qquad \Delta x = x_B-x_A = +600\ \text{m}
  1. Calculate the relative speed and Lorentz factor:
v=+0.60(3.00×108)=+1.80×108 m s−1v = +0.60(3.00 \times 10^8) = +1.80 \times 10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1} γ=11−v2/c2=11−0.602=1.25\gamma = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1-v^2/c^2}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1-0.60^2}} = 1.25
  1. Substitute into the time transformation:
Δt′=−γvΔxc2=−1.25(1.80×108)(600)(3.00×108)2 s=−1.5×10−6 s=−1.5 μs\Delta t' = -\frac{\gamma v\Delta x}{c^2} = -\frac{1.25(1.80 \times 10^8)(600)}{(3.00 \times 10^8)^2}\ \text{s} = -1.5 \times 10^{-6}\ \text{s} = -1.5\ \mu\text{s}
Answer

Answer: Δt′=−1.5 μs\Delta t' = -1.5\ \mu\text{s}. Since tB′−tA′<0t'_B-t'_A<0, B occurs first in S′, 1.5 μs1.5\ \mu\text{s} before A.

Exam tip: If asked to explain the negative sign, state that B has an earlier time coordinate than A in S′ because the difference is defined as B minus A. Reporting “the time difference is negative” does not explain the event order.

The moving-carriage picture

A useful picture is a lamp at the centre of a moving carriage. In the carriage frame, the light reaches the front and rear ends at the same time. In the platform frame, the rear end moves towards the light while the front end moves away, so the rear event happens first. This is not a delay-of-seeing problem. We imagine each frame filled with local observers, using synchronized clocks at the event positions.

Reading a spacetime diagram

On a spacetime diagram, events that are simultaneous in one frame lie along a line parallel to that frame’s space axis. Since different frames have differently tilted space axes, they cut spacetime into “same time” slices in different ways.

A.5.8

SPACETIME DIAGRAMS AND WORLD LINES

HL

Reading a spacetime diagram

A spacetime diagram graphs position along one space axis horizontally, with time on the vertical axis. In most diagrams the vertical axis is labelled ctct rather than tt. Since ctct has units of metres, both axes can be read as distance axes.

A world line is the curve on a spacetime diagram that traces the sequence of events occupied by a particle or object. In this course, moving particles have constant velocity, so their world lines are straight.

  • A particle at rest in the diagram’s frame has a vertical world line.
  • A particle moving at constant speed has a straight, tilted world line.
  • A photon in vacuum has a world line at 45° to the x and ctct axes, provided these axes use equal distance scales on the page.

The angle between a particle’s world line and the time axis gives its speed when xx and ctct use equal distance scales on the page:

tan⁡θ=vc\tan\theta = \frac{v}{c}

For light, v=cv=c, so tan⁡θ=1\tan\theta=1 and θ=45∘\theta=45^\circ.

With unequal plotting scales, calculate speed from coordinate differences, not the drawn angle: v/c=Δx/Δ(ct)v/c=\Delta x/\Delta(ct).

Worked example: A world line passes through (x,ct)=(0,0)(x,ct)=(0,0) and (600 m,1000 m)(600\ \text{m},1000\ \text{m}). Find the elapsed time, velocity and angle to the time axis for equal plotting scales. Use c=3.00×108 m s−1c=3.00\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}.

  1. Convert the vertical coordinate difference to time: Δt=Δ(ct)c=1000 m3.00×108 m s−1=3.33 μs\Delta t=\frac{\Delta(ct)}{c}=\frac{1000\ \text{m}}{3.00\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}}=3.33\ \mu\text{s}
  2. Calculate velocity using the unrounded time: v=ΔxΔt=600 m1000 m/c=0.60c=1.80×108 m s−1v=\frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t}=\frac{600\ \text{m}}{1000\ \text{m}/c}=0.60c=1.80\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}
  3. Calculate the angle: θ=arctan⁡(0.60)=31.0∘\theta=\arctan(0.60)=31.0^\circ
Answer

Answer: The elapsed time is 3.33 μs3.33\ \mu\text{s}, the velocity is 0.60c=1.80×108 m s−10.60c=1.80\times10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}, and the angle is 31.0∘31.0^\circ.

Common mistake: Δ(ct)/Δx\Delta(ct)/\Delta x gives c/vc/v, not v/cv/c. For the angle measured from the time axis, use horizontal change divided by vertical change.

Two frames on one diagram

For a second inertial frame S′S' moving relative to SS, the ct′ct'-axis is the world line of the S′S' origin. The x′x'-axis marks the line of simultaneity for S′S' at t′=0t'=0. Both axes tilt towards the photon lines; they do not rotate like ordinary Euclidean axes.

The scales on ctct, ct′ct', xx and x′x' are not identical. They are set using lines of constant spacetime interval, often drawn as invariant hyperbolas. So don't just measure along a tilted axis using the same ruler scale as the untilted axis, unless the diagram has been explicitly calibrated.

To read an event’s primed coordinates, project parallel to the other primed axis, not perpendicular to the axis being read. For v=0.60cv=0.60c, the event PP at (x,ct)=(1000 m,1000 m)(x,ct)=(1000\ \text{m},1000\ \text{m}) has x′=500 mx'=500\ \text{m} and ct′=500 mct'=500\ \text{m}. Each tick on the calibrated axes represents 500 m500\ \text{m}.

Time dilation, length contraction and simultaneity can all be shown geometrically on these diagrams.

  • Lines parallel to a frame’s space axis show equal time in that frame.
  • Lines parallel to a frame’s time axis show objects at rest in that frame.

The algebra of Lorentz transformations and the geometry of spacetime diagrams are two ways of describing the same physics.

A.5.9

MUON DECAY AS EXPERIMENTAL EVIDENCE

HL

Atmospheric muons

A muon is an unstable subatomic particle made high in the atmosphere when high-energy cosmic rays hit air molecules. Muons have a short proper mean lifetime, so if you use a Newtonian calculation, almost none should make it down to detectors at Earth’s surface.

Yet plenty of muons are detected at ground level. From Earth’s frame, time dilation explains this: fast-moving muons have longer lifetimes, so more of them survive the trip down. From the muon’s own frame, the same result comes from length contraction: the atmosphere’s thickness is contracted, putting the ground much closer. These aren’t two competing physical effects. They are two frame descriptions of the same invariant spacetime story.

Worked example: Muons have proper mean lifetime τ0=2.2 μs\tau_0 = 2.2\ \mu\text{s} and speed v=0.998cv = 0.998c. They form 10 km10\ \text{km} above the ground. Compare travel distances and explain ground-level detections, using c=3.00×108 m s−1c = 3.00 \times 10^8\ \text{m s}^{-1}.

  1. Calculate the Lorentz factor: γ=11−(0.998)2≈15.8\gamma = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1-(0.998)^2}} \approx 15.8
  2. Without time dilation, the mean travel distance is: vτ0=0.998(3.00×108)(2.2×10−6) m≈0.66 kmv\tau_0 = 0.998(3.00 \times 10^8)(2.2 \times 10^{-6})\ \text{m} \approx 0.66\ \text{km}
  3. In Earth’s frame, the mean travel distance is: vγτ0=0.998(3.00×108)(15.8)(2.2×10−6) m≈10.4 kmv\gamma\tau_0 = 0.998(3.00 \times 10^8)(15.8)(2.2 \times 10^{-6})\ \text{m} \approx 10.4\ \text{km}
  4. In the muon frame, the contracted atmospheric thickness and ground-arrival time are: L=1015.8 km≈0.63 kmL = \frac{10}{15.8}\ \text{km} \approx 0.63\ \text{km} t=Lv≈0.63×1030.998(3.00×108) s≈2.1 μst = \frac{L}{v} \approx \frac{0.63 \times 10^3}{0.998(3.00 \times 10^8)}\ \text{s} \approx 2.1\ \mu\text{s}

Mean lifetime is statistical, not a fixed expiry time: individual muons can decay earlier or later.

Answer

Answer: In Earth’s frame, time dilation increases the mean travel distance from 0.66 km0.66\ \text{km} to 10.4 km10.4\ \text{km}, allowing many more muons to survive to ground-level detectors. Equivalently, in the muon frame, length contraction lets the ground arrive in about 2.1 μs2.1\ \mu\text{s}, less than the proper mean lifetime.

A typical experiment compares muon counts at high altitude with counts at lower altitude. Without relativity, the predicted lower-altitude count comes out much too small. When time dilation is included, the prediction matches observation. That makes muon decay a particularly clean piece of evidence: not a rocket-based thought experiment, but a measurable particle-decay result.

Muon decay experiments therefore provide experimental evidence for both time dilation and length contraction. They also show that special relativity isn’t just for science fiction; it is built into particle physics, accelerator physics and technologies that rely on very precise timing.

Were those notes helpful?

A.4 Rigid body mechanics