The student demonstrates a thorough understanding of the literal meaning of Banksy's Ukraine collection through detailed analysis of the murals, effectively discussing their content, context, and composition. They convincingly interpret the indirect meanings, highlighting themes of hope and resilience, particularly through the symbolism of perseverance in the artworks. However, the student needs to improve the thesis statement in the introductory paragraph to make it clearer and more focused on the specific themes and techniques analyzed. While the analysis and conclusions align well with the thesis, the interpretation could benefit from deeper insights that connect the artworks to larger societal themes. Overall, the references chosen are relevant and effectively support the arguments presented in the essay.