The student demonstrated a thorough understanding of the literal meaning of Kafka's "The Metamorphosis," effectively analyzing Gregor Samsa's transformation and its implications in modern society. The interpretation of the indirect meaning is also convincing, particularly through the portrayal of Gregor as a Christ-like figure, highlighting deeper themes of human existence. However, the thesis statement lacks focus and clarity, which could have been improved for a more succinct argument. Despite this, the student successfully explored the thesis throughout the essay, maintaining a cohesive argument that ties back to the initial thesis in each body paragraph. Overall, the references chosen are well-integrated and support the analysis effectively.