The student has chosen an appropriate topic for their essay, focusing on narrative techniques in Margaret Atwood's *Alias Grace*, which aligns well with the requirements of English A, Category 1. They have articulated a clear and detailed research question that invites a thorough analysis of how Atwood's techniques challenge conventional ideas about history and truth. The introduction effectively presents the research question while outlining the reasoning behind its choice and the insights the analysis will offer. Furthermore, the student has incorporated a variety of sources, both primary and secondary, to support their arguments, demonstrating a solid understanding of the relationship between truth and historical representation. However, the essay lacks a discussion on the organization and structure, which is recommended for enhancing the clarity of the analysis.