The student has chosen an appropriate topic for their extended essay, focusing on Madeline Miller's "The Song of Achilles," which effectively aligns with the subject of English A Language and Literature. The student incorporates relevant source material, such as R.W. Connell's theory of masculinity, demonstrating a clear understanding of gender roles within the literary context. While the communication of ideas is generally clear, there are some issues with language precision, particularly in phrasing and terminology. The essay maintains a strong focus on the primary text, integrating secondary sources to enhance the analysis without overshadowing it. Overall, the student's exploration of masculinity is insightful and effectively framed within contemporary discussions.